Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

csvchain.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

61–70 of 171 posts

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#61

Post by ForgotMyPwOops »

folli wrote: post #51
ForgotMyPwOops wrote: post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My understanding is that this is not correct, it conflates all NFT transactions without nuance, if one buys intellectual property via NFT and can prove it (which is ostensibly NFT's raison d'etre) then I see no reason why they couldn't exercise their rights to it (i.e. sue for copyright infringement, ect)

So you need to fallback to centralized government to sue for copyright? How bourgoise.

Maybe I misunderstand your point but intellectual property can only exist under a legal system, this seems like a shallow 'gotcha'

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#62

Post by asciimike »

I see that CSVCHAIN is "held in cold storage on this USB drive" a 1 GB thumb drive. This seems to imply an upper bound on the number of NFTs on CSVCHAIN. How, I wonder, does the creator of this project expect to scale CSVCHAIN beyond this limit?

Additionally, can we secure guarantees that the project owner is safely ejecting the USB drive in question?

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#63

Post by weego »

asciimike wrote: post #62

I see that CSVCHAIN is "held in cold storage on this USB drive" a 1 GB thumb drive. This seems to imply an upper bound on the number of NFTs on CSVCHAIN. How, I wonder, does the creator of this project expect to scale CSVCHAIN beyond this limit? Additionally, can we secure guarantees that the project owner is safely ejecting the USB drive in question?

Once Roy makes some $ he could horizontally scale to a 2GB drive. Or 2 1GB drives and keep one in his sock draw so it's distributed in his house.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#64

Post by rfd4sgmk8u »

A4ET8a8uTh0 wrote: post #53
rfd4sgmk8u wrote: post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, this is gross. It implies that marriage certificates grants you the exclusive rights to have sex with another party.

Quite the opposite. Marriage is a legal contract that, among other things, bestows certain rights and obligations. There is a reason 'adultery' is something that counts as marital misconduct.

Uhhh.. obligations to sex? That is exactly what this analogy is saying. Its gross to assume that anyone owes you sex.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#65

Post by miracle2k »

I'm a huge NFT enthusiast and collector. This project gets NFTs exactly right. It's frankly refreshing to see someone seemingly get it - most of the critiques are just so bad. It's just that: I don't see the problem at all. I'd encourage you all to buy NFTs on CSVChain, ideally from real artists committed to their craft.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#66

Post by rburhum »

weego wrote: post #63
asciimike wrote: post #62

I see that CSVCHAIN is "held in cold storage on this USB drive" a 1 GB thumb drive. This seems to imply an upper bound on the number of NFTs on CSVCHAIN. How, I wonder, does the creator of this project expect to scale CSVCHAIN beyond this limit? Additionally, can we secure guarantees that the project owner is safely ejecting the USB drive in question?

Once Roy makes some $ he could horizontally scale to a 2GB drive. Or 2 1GB drives and keep one in his sock draw so it's distributed in his house.

I wish I could upvote this more

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#67

Post by pedrosorio »

rfd4sgmk8u wrote: post #64
A4ET8a8uTh0 wrote: post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quite the opposite. Marriage is a legal contract that, among other things, bestows certain rights and obligations. There is a reason 'adultery' is something that counts as marital misconduct.

Uhhh.. obligations to sex? That is exactly what this analogy is saying. Its gross to assume that anyone owes you sex.

> Its gross to assume that anyone owes you sex.

> your wife is being drilled by everyone and you can't do anything about it

I interpret this as "someone owes you to not have sex with other people" (which is a common assumption in most marriages), not that someone owes you sex...

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#68

Post by asciimike »

weego wrote: post #63
asciimike wrote: post #62

I see that CSVCHAIN is "held in cold storage on this USB drive" a 1 GB thumb drive. This seems to imply an upper bound on the number of NFTs on CSVCHAIN. How, I wonder, does the creator of this project expect to scale CSVCHAIN beyond this limit? Additionally, can we secure guarantees that the project owner is safely ejecting the USB drive in question?

Once Roy makes some $ he could horizontally scale to a 2GB drive. Or 2 1GB drives and keep one in his sock draw so it's distributed in his house.

In the event of using 2 1GB drives with one stored in the sock drawer, how do we prevent the quite literal "evil maid" attacks altering the CSVCHAIN?

Additionally, if we do use this mechanism, I petition to fork the name from CSVCHAIN to SockChain.

Re: CSVCHAIN - NFTs backed by CSV technology

#69

Post by kgwgk »

A4ET8a8uTh0 wrote: post #47
kgwgk wrote: post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No. You are the random guy and Opensea is the street. (And it’s not a picture/wife that you sell, is an NFT/certificate.)

Sure, but how am I different from million other guys on the street or Opensea. Lets start at the beginning. You have analogy wrong ( which is a problem with analogies - they are open to interpretation ). The joke part says the following: 1. You have a wife. 2. She is not behaving like your wife. 3. You have a marriage certificate saying she is your wife And NFTs follow the same pattern, because: NFTs say they are you…

Well, it seems you have your own analogy wrong ;-) [By the way, the “A marriage certificate that you bought from some random guy on the street and has no legal significance.” was not mine.]

If the NFT is the wife, what is the certificate?

Post reply on HN