Live data from Hacker News

NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

erickhun.com

61–70 of 264 posts

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#61
post #6

The only real future for NFT's is a coupling with the physical world. Like buying physical art. Or proofing ownership of an asset like houses.

Which will require the authority to recognize it. Your NFT of house is worth nothing unless court/police recognize it to be so.

Which kills the whole idea blockchain is based on: decentralization. It's a feedback loop with no known exact solution yet.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#62
post #53
post #10

I'm very surprised that those (the JSON and the picture) are not stored in a decentralised way e.g. IPFS or Swarm. So if I buy an expensive NFT, and the domain goes down, the NFT is now worthless? We should be on the lookout for any of these domains expiring, then we will buy them and upload Rick Astley GIFs

> So if I buy an expensive NFT, and the domain goes down, the NFT is now worthless? Well, that’s a question and a half. If its intrinsic value dropped to zero, would that be a change in value?

Thanks, you made my day

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#63

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

It's best to think of NFTs as deeds to the art (or certificate of authenticity), rather than the art itself.

I wrote this a little while back, and it might help you. https://interjectedfuture.com/nfts-unbundle-ownership-from-e...

If NFTs as deed to art isn't convincing for you, check out ENS. https://ens.domains/ It's a name registrar that's a smart contract. Each ENS domain name is an NFT.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#64

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

Hype. Hoping it will become even more popular to sell it for even higher.

Do you have any evidence to back this up? This isn’t a useful comment.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#65

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

I think it is a combination of The Greater Fool Theory and fear of missing out. If you missed out on Bitcoin, now is your chance to ride the next wave.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#66
I haven't studied NFTs but I will admit I had an misconceptions that the low pixel art NFTs purpose was that it was able to be stored on the chain itself as "it's own thing" or as a representation of a "bigger piece".

My question would then be.... why the lowres pixelated NFTs if they are being hosted somewhere else?

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#67

So how exactly is the "gas money" calculated? I was led to believe it was expensive because putting all that data into the blockchain costed a significant amount. Asking because, wanting to verify whether NFTs were really a scam or scheme instead of just following heated Twitter arguments, I looked into uploading my own NFT. Gas money for a single image was $250--estimated earnings for an NFT are in the low dollars f…

(just speaking for Ethereum)

The gas fees are a constant, so you pay a certain amount of ETH to mint your NFT. You don't upload any image data but solely the address (so a couple of bytes) of the owner.

The reason that this costs so much is the exponential increase in ETH prices in the recent years and the network congestions (gas price depends on the workload of the ETH network). What used to be a couple of cents or so is now easily $70, depending on the ETH price and network congestion.

I whipped up a calculator some time ago: https://nuftu.com/pricing

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#68

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

I think it's mostly speculative - the expectation that you can sell for a higher price (which often turns out to be true.)

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#69

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

Money laundering.

It’s not that simple.

Re: NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain

#70

I hate to admit it but I’m still struggling to understand why people would pay so much for NFTs. I feel like I fully understand what they are and why most people want me to believe it has value but I still don’t agree. I’m waiting for my mind to change but it hasn’t happened yet. It’s frustrating because so many people I respect are leaving their high paying jobs to work in web3 startups around NFTs and I feel dumb f…

This topic turned up a week ago. [0] Personally I like the analogy to baseball cards. From [0]:

> Owning an NFT generally doesn't grant you copyrights over the underlying work of art. Owning a baseball card doesn't mean the athlete now works for you. They can both still have value as collectible items, if that's something that interests you.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29050802

Post reply on HN