Live data from Hacker News

Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

mattstoller.substack.com

61–70 of 595 posts

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#61
post #30

How about Big Telecom and Big Fintech and Banking? Or is it simply because the rest did not pay enough to the lobbyists?

The ISPs have been getting hit in this series of orders. That said, yes, fintech and banking are conspicuously absent. Which kind of lets you know that they are just too powerful.

Banking is getting impacted in this series of executive orders, there’s a mandate that banks make customer financial history portable so that customers aren’t locked into continuing to use their current bank to keep their financial records. Aside from that issue that stops customers from being likely to switch banks, there’s a ton of competition in banking. There are many consumer banks, they all provide essentially the same services, and they compete on things like branch density, customer service, and saving/loan rates. Aside from that, consumer banking is already one of the most regulated industries.

Fintech consumer products and services are rare with the exception of tax preparation. E-trading is becoming more popular, but existing consumer banks and brokerages are stepping up to compete across the board. Intuit’s TurboTax product is really the only example I can think of in the fintech industry that needs antitrust attention.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#62
post #37

"Hearing aids cost thousands of dollars apiece, for no other reason than there is a cartel established by government that prevents firms from selling hearing aids without a prescription." An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. There are dozens of companies who would no doubt start making inexpensive hearing aids tomorr…

Queue "overpowered OTC aids destroyed my hearing" pushback...

*Cue

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#63

Big pharma is significantly less of a problem than the physician and hospital cartels. I have no idea why these groups have survived scrutiny for their literal multi-hundred million dollar lobbying/bribery of politicians. My closest guess is that we all know "My" physician or a well paid nurse that benefits from the bribery.

I don't see most physicians being an issue. Many of them are fed up with the insurance, pharma, and regulations. Most are forced to work for large providers instead of being independent just due to the overhead of dealing with digital record systems, legal, insurance billing, etc.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#64
post #58
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Queue private agency testing, evaluating and rating products on the market

Cue rating agencies passing anything because hearing aid companies can go to another rating company if they don't, like what happened with mortgage securities in the 00s...

Yeah, it is totally impossible to have competition on regulated market. Monopoly is only possible solution.

Or something.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#65
post #44

"Hearing aids cost thousands of dollars apiece, for no other reason than there is a cartel established by government that prevents firms from selling hearing aids without a prescription." An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. There are dozens of companies who would no doubt start making inexpensive hearing aids tomorr…

"monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection" The entire point of patents...

> The entire point of patents...

Well, if that were so, you would expect them to be secret and to never expire. The fact that are published and expire after a relatively short period belies the simplicity of that statement.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#66
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Elaborate? Out of the loop

It's a game of "Spot the Fox News viewer". If you're a fan, you believe the largest ethical quandary facing the nation in the last quarter-century is that a person related to the President of the United States is selling a painting in an anonymous auction. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/obama-ethics-chief-hunter-b...

> a person related to the President of the United States

The sitting president’s son, you mean?

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#67

"Hearing aids cost thousands of dollars apiece, for no other reason than there is a cartel established by government that prevents firms from selling hearing aids without a prescription." An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. There are dozens of companies who would no doubt start making inexpensive hearing aids tomorr…

>An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture.

To be clear this "legal authorization or protection" is not necessarily over regulation. Depending on the market, sometimes monopolies are the result of too much government regulation and sometimes they are the result of not enough government regulation. For example, most of the big tech monopolies do not exist because of regulatory capture. They exist because the government never put in enough effort to stop the monopolies from forming.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#68
post #41

Sort of good, but we'll see how it plays out without other policies supporting it. Frankly, many consolidations are not malicious but necessary for survival. Economies of scale and verticle integration are required to complete with foreign companies with lower costs. Look at domestic steel production. No way the market can support numerous domestic options that can compete with the low cost of foreign imports. Then t…

What are some uses for honey by the pound? Off topic but curious, I only ever put it in tea rarely or simmiliarly rarely use it as a sugar alternative when cooking.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#69
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection" The entire point of patents...

It was not great before patents when a big company could steal your work and put you out of business after you put in the R&D effort.

Yeah, that used to be the point of patents. Now it seems it's mostly to squeeze as much out of people by capturing the majority of the market by not allowing similar products.

I mean, we have CEOs of biomedical companies admitting that they aren't basing prices off of what it costs to research, develop, and deliver a therapy, but rather base it off of what a deaparare person is willing to pay for it. This is the very thing antitrust laws were supposed to prevent, but the patent system is used to create a similar environment.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#70
post #67

"Hearing aids cost thousands of dollars apiece, for no other reason than there is a cartel established by government that prevents firms from selling hearing aids without a prescription." An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. There are dozens of companies who would no doubt start making inexpensive hearing aids tomorr…

>An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. To be clear this "legal authorization or protection" is not necessarily over regulation. Depending on the market, sometimes monopolies are the result of too much government regulation and sometimes they are the result of not enough government regulation. For example, most of the…

> For example, most of the big tech monopolies do not exist because of regulatory capture. They exist because the government never put in enough effort to stop the monopolies from forming.

Is it possible they exist because the immense economies of scale and near zero marginal cost that software provides makes for a winner take all market?

As a customer, why would one use the 2nd best option, when the best option is available at no extra cost or very little cost?

Post reply on HN