Live data from Hacker News

China accused of forcing 570k people to pick cotton in Xinjiang

reuters.com

61–64 of 64 posts

Re: China accused of forcing 570k people to pick cotton in Xinjiang

#61

[flagged]

I'm pretty uninformed on this topic. Can some explain why the parent comment would get downvoted?

Nationalistic and ideological flamewar are not what this site is for, and people are routinely descending into near-madness about this. The comments are predictable, over the top, and unbelievably lame. Users who want to yell at each other and blare national/ideological rhetoric need to post elsewhere. Boilerplate talking points belong elsewhere also.

This is becoming epidemic on HN. I think we are going to have to ask the community to get a lot more systematic about flagging comments that flout this site's rules and intended spirit—regardless of which side of the battle they're on.

This is the point at which some angry zealot accuses us of being secret communist agents. Not at all—we're just trying to have an internet forum that isn't dominated by cartoonish ideological and nationalistic yelling. Grandiose rhetoric is not intellectually interesting, so this follows from what we're trying to optimize for: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor....

Re: China accused of forcing 570k people to pick cotton in Xinjiang

#63
post #35

How come a link to REUTERS article, with the exact headline is flagged?

There is only one way to flag an article here. For a lot of people to click flag. And given this happening 7:00 San Jose time, I doubt any of mods would be logging into their mod account first thing in the morning to manually flag it. Still telling. Tech industry has a lot of communists.

This breaks the site guidelines egregiously. It's also a cartoonish fantasy of the sort that makes me cringe for this community. Please do not post any more of this dross.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re: China accused of forcing 570k people to pick cotton in Xinjiang

#64
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is only one way to flag an article here. For a lot of people to click flag. And given this happening 7:00 San Jose time, I doubt any of mods would be logging into their mod account first thing in the morning to manually flag it. Still telling. Tech industry has a lot of communists.

But why is it still flagged 4 hours later? The HN mods can and do turn off user flags on important stories. Edit: why is this being downvoted? You've never seen dang turn off flags? He admits it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15510075 So that raises the question: why not turn off flags on this story?

Because these threads are dominated by cartoonish, angry yelling which contains zero intellectual curiosity and therefore is thoroughly off topic. The commenters inundating the threads on these topics are plainly posting out of nationalistic and ideological zeal. That's not what HN is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26630172

Post reply on HN