Live data from Hacker News

Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

youtube.com

61–70 of 517 posts

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#61

NASA's ability of succeeding at landing things successfully on the first try on foreign bodies since 1969 is mind-blowing. Meanwhile, SpaceX takes half a dozen tries before managing to do the same on a fully known environment on Earth.

Lets just say both are doing very important work with very different incentives

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#63

It's a great achievement with some really interesting work done on the landing algorithms with terrain recognition and it seemed to have worked exceptionally well. Looking forward for the next landing in May of the Chinese rover and all the science these robots will produce. Also, the test of Ingenuity, the helicopter, will be very interesting to watch, that could really pave the way for a different exploration style…

Ingenuity is maybe the most interesting and coolest advance for space travel. The idea of a remote drone to explore Mars is just rad! I can totally nerd out about that!

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#67

NASA's ability of succeeding at landing things successfully on the first try on foreign bodies since 1969 is mind-blowing. Meanwhile, SpaceX takes half a dozen tries before managing to do the same on a fully known environment on Earth.

You had me until you started to bash SpaceX for no reason. NASA has had plenty of failures and you're framing it as if they haven't ever.

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#68
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

NASA also requires 10-100x more money & time to do so. Both just have very different ways of working. Both work and there are pro's and con's to either way!

How could you know? SpaceX never landed or sent a craft on a foreign body.

Haha, good point - we'll have to come back in 4-5 years time when SpaceX have touched down on the moon and mars and check the cost. Considering their low cost & speed at getting things into orbit these days and the plans they have for starship I hope that the data will prove me right in a few years

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#69

NASA's ability of succeeding at landing things successfully on the first try on foreign bodies since 1969 is mind-blowing. Meanwhile, SpaceX takes half a dozen tries before managing to do the same on a fully known environment on Earth.

That snipe was really unnecessary.

Not to mention weird, considering how successful SpaceX has been at dominating the commercial launch sector.

Re: Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]

#70

NASA's ability of succeeding at landing things successfully on the first try on foreign bodies since 1969 is mind-blowing. Meanwhile, SpaceX takes half a dozen tries before managing to do the same on a fully known environment on Earth.

Consider for a second that blowing up no prototypes or blowing up lots of prototypes are both well considered methodologies and what you state is by design and expected.
Post reply on HN