Live data from Hacker News

Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

onezero.medium.com

61–70 of 136 posts

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#61

For me, Nextdoor is primarily people looking for lost pets, complaining about "suspicious" strangers, and making dubious crime reports. That's hardly a replacement for a local newspaper.

The feed in my neighborhood might be a little different, but I think you forgot to mention real estate listings and ads for surveillance cameras.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#62
I don't remember local or small-town papers to [generally] being toxic or cesspools of hate.

However, one of my True Jokes is "NextDoor: Hate Your Neighbors" just as "Facebook: Hate Your Family & Friends" and "Twitter: Hate Your Heroes".

NextDoor sounds good, but it generally proves not. Everything from "suspicious teenagers on the sidewalk again" [meaning: local kids walking to their local home from the local school but Nosey Nancy is too busy "Taking Notes & Reporting To Police"] to "if public transit comes here so will the meth-head homeless pulling the rug out from under my overpriced house" [reality is baseless fears about recycling, commuting, and less cars on the road].

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#63

For me, Nextdoor is primarily people looking for lost pets, complaining about "suspicious" strangers, and making dubious crime reports. That's hardly a replacement for a local newspaper.

This is the best and most generous description of NextDoor I have found so far.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#64
post #46

No, it is not. The small town paper where I live sends someone to sit through city council meetings, which at times decide important things, but often debate relatively unimportant things in lengthly, excruciating detail. Like that time I went to comment about a housing issue that was important to me and had to sit through a discussion of the city sign code. In any event, even people who care about one thing or the o…

Well, you're lucky. Where I am, the education report appears to just rephrase whatever they get from the teachers union.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#65

I don't remember local or small-town papers to [generally] being toxic or cesspools of hate. However, one of my True Jokes is "NextDoor: Hate Your Neighbors" just as "Facebook: Hate Your Family & Friends" and "Twitter: Hate Your Heroes". NextDoor sounds good, but it generally proves not. Everything from "suspicious teenagers on the sidewalk again" [meaning: local kids walking to their local home from the local school…

This sounds very judgmental about NextDoor users. They are voicing their concerns about their neighborhood and community. Why do you have to say anything about their community, especially if you don't live there?

You also have the right to voice concerns about your neighborhood and community. I would assume you want others to respect your right to voice your concerns, just as they would expect you to respect their right to voice their concerns.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#66

For me, Nextdoor is primarily people looking for lost pets, complaining about "suspicious" strangers, and making dubious crime reports. That's hardly a replacement for a local newspaper.

The feed in my neighborhood might be a little different, but I think you forgot to mention real estate listings and ads for surveillance cameras.

> ads for surveillance cameras

How much of that advertisement is based off of "Paranoid Paige" with too much time on their hands?

Not to necessarily rail against using metrics, but metrics can be tilted -- if everyone's Paranoid Paige, how deep and legit is that gold mine?

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#67
post #7

Maybe it is just my nextdoor area but very little relevant community information is found, in fact most all discussions of schools, local politics, and HOAs immediately disappear. Most posts are looking for a local service provider or missing pets. That coupled with the non chronological feeds make me think that Nextdoor only wants to become an Angie's List and not a source of actual good for my community.

Nextdoor wants to make money. It's hard to make money and do good

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#68

For me, Nextdoor is primarily people looking for lost pets, complaining about "suspicious" strangers, and making dubious crime reports. That's hardly a replacement for a local newspaper.

don't forget about every loud sound being "gunshots??"

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The fines should be proportionate to income to pay for the program but this would work https://time.com/4552903/mislata-spain-dog-feces/

it should be for all crimes

It is in most places I think ?)

At least every country I lived so far (not that I’m a vagrant criminal lol)

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

- I oppose growing education bureaucracy where little of the increase in education funding goes to teacher salary, and instead to rent-seeking bureaucrats that waste tax-payer money - Public schools have failed kids in the US due to overly powerful teachers unions who protect terrible teacher and do injustice to students prospects. I'd rather pay for charter schools, not some general state education budget.

You're simultaneously claiming that not enough money goes to teachers salaries and that the teachers unions are too powerful. I'm not really sure I follow.

Not enough money goes to good teachers and too much money goes to bad teachers.

Teachers unions enable bad teachers by excusing their behavior. Doesn't do much to help good teachers.

What does teachers unions do to help good teachers become better teachers and helping students?

Teachers unions help bad teachers by preventing vast majority from being fired for being bad teachers. Everyone knows who the bad teachers are in the system.

Teachers unions make money by controlling the teachers and politicians in the system.

Post reply on HN