Live data from Hacker News

VPN by Google One

one.google.com

61–70 of 129 posts

Re: VPN by Google One

#61
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only if in your mind "VPN" equals "anonymity and privacy" (which it shouldn't).

What should a VPN be for if not privacy?

Some public networks (like those at airports and coffee shops) still do sketchy things like injecting ads into HTTP sites and breaking DNS. A VPN is a great solution to these problems.

Re: VPN by Google One

#62
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

$10/mo is way more expensive than most VPN offerings. I've been paying something around $2.50/mo for Private Internet Access for years now.

Why pay $10 to have my ass tracked, when I can have my ass tracked for free

[deleted]

Re: VPN by Google One

#63
post #17

Never in a million years would I trust google as my VPN provider. 1) No customer support 2) it will probably be cancelled in 18 months 3) they already spy on me enough with search, android, google keyboard, gmail

You have to pay money for this. One of the features they advertise is: "Premium support on everything Google".

So, no customer support for non-paying customers, but I don't think that applies here.

Re: VPN by Google One

#64
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there really an issue if it gets cancelled? You can just get a new VPN. It’s not like other google products where you’re going to lose data or have to rebuild systems.

It's still a pain setting up a new one and learning its quirks. If there was a compelling reason otherwise, might be worth it. Can't think of any upside myself, even the price isn't good.

> Can't think of any upside myself, even the price isn't good.

The price is zero if you are already on that Google One tier, which is pretty good.

Whether its good if you aren't depends on not just the VPN service itself, but how much you value the other things provided by Google One.

Re: VPN by Google One

#65
I find it strange that they’re tying this VPN to a subscription with drive, gmail, and google photos. Who cares if the VPN logs are anonymizes if I’m using the VPN to upload all my files and send emails to the same account as the VPN?

Re: VPN by Google One

#66
> Google will never use the VPN connection to track, log or sell your browsing activity¹

I like the honesty here. Oftentimes you learn more about someone's intention by paying attention to the omissions.

Re: VPN by Google One

#68
post #17

Never in a million years would I trust google as my VPN provider. 1) No customer support 2) it will probably be cancelled in 18 months 3) they already spy on me enough with search, android, google keyboard, gmail

i was just about to say -- now they can just read from your dns directly :) guess don't use 8.8.8.8 either :)

Re: VPN by Google One

#69
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Google will never use the VPN connection to track, log, or sell your browsing activity¹" "1. Some minimum logging is performed to ensure quality of service, but your network traffic is never logged and your IP is not associated to your activity." Even with that fairly well spelled out promise, I trust google about as much as I trust $RANDO_VPN, so... hardly at all?

> your IP is not associated to your activity Does this mean your incoming IP, or your outgoing IP? And if payment info or Google identity is associated with your activity, why would they need to bother associating an IP to your activity?

If you read the article then you would already know the answer to this question. They are using a blinding protocol so that the service that terminates the VPN is unaware of the identity of the user.
Post reply on HN