Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

balena.io

61–69 of 69 posts

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#61
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Super job. More nitpicking: the real fanatics line up the screw heads to the geometry of the piece. For instance the Dekatrons would look nicer if the screwhead slots would form a circle too.

You're totally right of course, I was very afraid of snapping those little guys off :)

Quarter turn before breaking is the right torque ;) Again, super job. Be prepared for a lot of brass polishing.

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#62

Looks fantastic! Well done! Why didn't you go full brass on the decatrons, instead of mixing stainless and copper? Same goes for the counter box: you only wrapped 2 sides when you pro'lly could have wrapped the whole thing in brass... you probably saved yourself 10 hours by not doing that, but you're already in for what, 30 hours already? Now I'm going to nitpick. :) My only critique is the high gloss finish on the w…

I know a lot of people don't like being criticized, but this is exactly the sort of criticism I like when I finish a project.

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#63
I wanted to work with dekatrons (my initials are dek) but the actual dekatron tubes want 300+V, which exceeds my personal comfort level. However there is a nice kit with all the necessary electronics: https://threeneurons.wordpress.com/dekatron-stuff/variable-d...

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#64
post #60
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I assumed that someone had made a sensitive bolometer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolometer Wood is a thermal insulator, so with care, one might be able to build a thermistor bridge capable of detecting the differential temperature rise between pieces of brass when a source was placed near one brass-piece. I, too, found that the expectations framed by the title were not met by the article. It's a pretty box, thoug…

>By 1880, Langley's bolometer was refined enough to detect thermal radiation from a cow a quarter of a mile away. Sidenote: that sounds like even F-22/35 should be visible half a globe away in IR

Be careful of that inverse square law—it's a doozy!

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#65
post #63

I wanted to work with dekatrons (my initials are dek) but the actual dekatron tubes want 300+V, which exceeds my personal comfort level. However there is a nice kit with all the necessary electronics: https://threeneurons.wordpress.com/dekatron-stuff/variable-d...

I wonder how many people ever get to work with equipment that has the same name as they do!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#66
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Building a Geiger tube is probably beyond the reach of most people. That’s a precision piece of equipment.

I'd argue that it is beyond the perceived reach of many people, but it is not beyond the actual reach of many people. The key ingredients are aspiration and time.

Another commenter on hacker news completely out of touch with the lives the vast majority of humanity lives. It's amazing how the simplistic intellectual masturbation here is similar to reddit except with reddit it's because they are teenagers and here it's because the users are just basic enough to make decent enough and not much more than that.

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#67
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Building a Geiger tube is probably beyond the reach of most people. That’s a precision piece of equipment.

I'd argue that it is beyond the perceived reach of many people, but it is not beyond the actual reach of many people. The key ingredients are aspiration and time.

This got me thinking: how far down the current human tech tree could a single person get on their own? It took thousands of years for humans to go from fire to the steam locomotive; could someone do it in a lifetime?

Obviously the ability to skip by basic research and dead ends would cut this down by a ton, but ultimately a lot of the things we’ve created in the past century requires a huge amount of complicated machinery to make, which requires more machines and more labor. Could a person reasonably start from scratch (let’s say skip the mining and just give them coal & metal ores) and make a Geiger tube? Or would it be too difficult?

Re: Show HN: I built a desktop radiation monitor with Raspberry Pi, brass and wood

#68
post #12

Lovely piece of work. Scary how active those old gas lamp mantles are (in the video). Makes me wonder how radioactive your average campsite is, given that those things tend to crumble to dust when you change them.

Not very. The predominant isotope of thorium is an alpha emitter with a half-life measured in tens of billions of years. Looking at the video, the counter appears to peak around 200cpm, or (per the Grafana dashboard screenshot) about 2 microsieverts per hour. That'd take 50 hours, a little over two days, of exposure to add up to the dose of a typical chest X-ray. And that's for a whole mantle, placed directly adjacen…

For comparison I have seen statistics that a granite countertop, or granite flooring can emit around 1.7 microsieverts per hour. Granite is mildly radioactive. I imagine working in an old 1920s era office building with granite column facing materials and granite hallway flooring would be a lot more radiation load on the body, unless you spent dedicated time every day seeking out and handling gas lamp mantles.

Lots of people have marble and granite countertops in their kitchen...

Post reply on HN