Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

aws.amazon.com

61–70 of 331 posts

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#61
post #7

Ok honestly, my first thought was "here we go again", BUT when you look at the @jeffbar provided, you can see, that yes, it is "visual" programming. It does however require a certain logical fluency. So I was wrong: It is _not_ the sales/ceo dream of no longer having pesky engineers. It's a proper gateway drug into programming.

The most common fallacy across almost 40 years of visual programming attempts is that one can somehow escape the essential complexity of a problem domain. One must have "a certain logical fluency" to design essentially any process, regardless of the technology used.

Right, even extreme Excel macros require logic, and is also a programming gateway. The nice thing about Excel (or the article's example of Visicalc) is that one doesn't need to jump into the deep end of logic problem solving, at least at first.

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#63

Has programming 'without writing code' ever panned out for anyone? 27th times the charm?

Ladder logic used to be fairly big in PLCs a while ago, but PLCs were rather simple.

frontpage98 was the one to kickstart my web experience.

They are good to start somewhere from, but they'll never be a replacement.

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#64
This looks like several Microsoft products stacked together, Sharepoint, Forms, Flow, Power Apps. I already do this with Microsoft and most of the time I don't have all of the tools I need or I want to scream at the screen "just show me the code!".

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#65

I am working on a product in this space. I think pretty much all the 'no code' apps that are coming out have taken the wrong approach to it. No matter what, they are still 'designed' by programmers with a programming mentality. This will lead to a sort of failure as people will feel limited when using it, and a 'non programmer' mentality looks at this and goes wtf? For example: > =Filter(Tasks,"Tasks[Done] % ORDER BY…

There is a very large target audience which is technical enough to write Excel formulas but not enough to build an app. Your mother or father will never need to use this tool as it is, but those people will.

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#68
post #3

Looks like a competitor to Retool, interesting. The focus on data permissions, mobile support, and push notifications is really interesting because none of those features are ones that Retool focuses on, I believe - those features being front and center makes me think Amazon has looked at the competition and wants to focus on what they offer that others don't, rather than just trying to be yet-another-tool in the spa…

Hi there! Founder of Retool (https://retool.com) here (and long-time HN reader). Agreed that Honeycode is adjacent to us. I think an interesting way of viewing the space [1] is who the product is for. There are lots of drag and drop app-builders (e.g. mendix, outsystems, bubble, msft powerapps, amazon honeycode, etc.), but they're all built for non-technical people. Their goal is to make programming more accessible to all. (Which I think is a very noble and very interesting goal!)

Our bet, however, is that code is here to stay, since code is actually a pretty efficient way of getting a computer to do something [2]. With that said, though, building specific types of apps (in our case, internal front-end apps today) is surprisingly difficult (have you tried recently!? you have to use react, redux, install 10+ npm modules, etc... just to make a front-end that has a table + POSTs back to your internal API!).

And so that's why we're building Retool for engineers, which has resulted in a few interesting decisions:

* we are not a system of record, since engineers don't like to move data around. We'll connect to your data, no matter where it is (e.g. postgres, a custom API, salesforce, etc.).

* we rely on the user knowing how to write code. I think this is interesting because low-code is good for getting to 50%, 60%, etc. But as you try to get closer and closer to 100%, it becomes harder and harder, since full customizability within a GUI (without code) is just hard (cf 2.). Retool lets you get to 60 - 70% of what you want very quickly, but then relies on you finishing the last ~30% with code, if you really want to. (We provide APIs, let you import custom React components, let you write JS anywhere [3] within {{ }}.

this also has led us to embracing git syncing (serializing retool apps as yaml files and syncing them to git repos: https://docs.retool.com/docs/git-syncing ), being on-prem by default (https://docs.retool.com/docs/setup-instructions), etc.

(If anybody is interested in working on this, please email me at david AT retool DOT com. I think there's really a small chance we can really change how business apps are built.)

1. Funnily enough, when we started Retool, there was no low-code / no-code space. If you look at our original Show HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17725966), you'll see that nobody mentions "no code", "low code", or anything siilar. It's certainly been fun to watch a "trend" pick up around us, haha.

2. For example, imagine a switch statement. Very simple and concise in most languages, but incredibly hard to implement in a GUI. (A graph with nodes and edges, perhaps?)

3. We secure it by running all JS in a sandboxed iframe.

Re: Amazon Honeycode – build web and mobile apps without writing code

#70
post #41

I focused a bit on the history of computing when i was getting my CS degree and one of the things I've found super interesting is that for at least forty years (perhaps longer!) we've been at least academically interested in writing code "without writing code". It never really works, however for a technical person it can be a great way to do, like, a sketch. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=without+writing+code is an intere…

im genuinely asking myself if "this time is different". The merging of Cloud + Software consumerism of 15 (ish) years of mobile + software eats world can make the Bubbles, Airtable and other no/low code tools the next long tail revolution of software ? What is different from the front page + Dreamweaver + flash days ? My hint : cloud computing and the hosting of database AND logic in bigcorp maintained garden

I'm not sure what your point is. When you say "bubbles" and "software eats the world" I think you are saying that these tools were supposed to replace programming, but so far they haven't.

In fact I think that people who make that claim are wrong. Low code development tools have become hysterically successful, especially in recent years. WordPress (400+ million websites) has 50000+ plugins that can do almost anything. Look at Salesforce (17 billion revenue) and PeopleSoft. Airtable (1.1 billion valuation). Shopify is approaching 1 million sites. Wix has $600 million in revenue. There are a lot of other massively successful products that fit into the loose association you gave.

Post reply on HN