Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

simpdf.com

61–70 of 78 posts

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#61

Congratulations for the launch. Looks nice. For those that are cautious uploading sensitive PDFs, you can always just open them with Inkscape, and start editing pretty much anything in a document. PS: I was once forwarded an application for someone who was supposed to replace me, and I had to interview them. The expected salary was hidden by placing a gray rectangle over it. I removed it using inkscape and saw the ex…

qpdf also helps peeking safely

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#62
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Inkscape to Illustrator is what GIMP is to Photoshop. Glade someone brought it. For most common tasks is there really a point even using Photoshop and Illustrator now days? Especially with the cloud direction they are moving towards.

because GIMP sucks, maybe, and also because most people are required to interoperate with the rest of the profession. i am very disappointed that photoshop et al cannot be run under WINE :(

I use GIMP regularly and find it more than enough for all my needs.

I don't agree with you that it sucks.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#63
post #29

I really wish the PDF layout was easier to parse. No matter which library you use, you always run into edge cases which make text selection and extraction an issue on certain files. I was recently extracting financial data from a bank which provides only PDFs and every time they changed the format just a little bit I had to change large parts of my code to extract the transactions I wanted.

PDF is designed to present a human-readable document, not to serve as a data interchange format.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#64
post #58

So it claims to > Edit pdf like a word doc while preserving structure and format. While I'm sure there are cases where this works pretty well and can be very useful, it may be worth noting that -- just like every other tool in this space -- there will be many PDFs where it simply can't work. It'll be hugely dependent on exactly how the PDF-generating application/tool went about things. One simple example: suppose you…

I learned a lot from this article (discovered on HN I think):

What's so hard about PDF text extraction? https://www.filingdb.com/pdf-text-extraction

In a nutshell, PDF is fundamentally different than MS Word: it's a standard for visual layout, without notions of paragraphs or even words.

As OP said, it doesn't mean the tool is useless. It could quite often come handy for myself.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#65
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Inkscape to Illustrator is what GIMP is to Photoshop. Glade someone brought it. For most common tasks is there really a point even using Photoshop and Illustrator now days? Especially with the cloud direction they are moving towards.

because GIMP sucks, maybe, and also because most people are required to interoperate with the rest of the profession. i am very disappointed that photoshop et al cannot be run under WINE :(

I have done/still do complex composition and editing in both GIMP and Photoshop, and there is really no missing features in GIMP. If you go into using GIMP expecting it to be PShop, you will always be disappointed, but in reality that is only a good thing.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#66
post #58

So it claims to > Edit pdf like a word doc while preserving structure and format. While I'm sure there are cases where this works pretty well and can be very useful, it may be worth noting that -- just like every other tool in this space -- there will be many PDFs where it simply can't work. It'll be hugely dependent on exactly how the PDF-generating application/tool went about things. One simple example: suppose you…

I learned a lot from this article (discovered on HN I think): What's so hard about PDF text extraction? https://www.filingdb.com/pdf-text-extraction In a nutshell, PDF is fundamentally different than MS Word: it's a standard for visual layout, without notions of paragraphs or even words. As OP said, it doesn't mean the tool is useless. It could quite often come handy for myself.

One of the weirdest things I've seen is a PDF where the text is complete gibberish if you copy paste, but perfect if you export it to HTML or Word in Acrobat. Never figured out how or why that might happen.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#67
post #51

Congratulations for the launch. Looks nice. For those that are cautious uploading sensitive PDFs, you can always just open them with Inkscape, and start editing pretty much anything in a document. PS: I was once forwarded an application for someone who was supposed to replace me, and I had to interview them. The expected salary was hidden by placing a gray rectangle over it. I removed it using inkscape and saw the ex…

Inkscape to Illustrator is what GIMP is to Photoshop. Glade someone brought it. For most common tasks is there really a point even using Photoshop and Illustrator now days? Especially with the cloud direction they are moving towards.

I've been incredibly happy with the Affinity Suite. Smoother and cleaner than GIMP/Inkscape/Scribus, and a desktop app for $50 ($25 during Covid), which makes it more palatable to me than the Adobe options.

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I learned a lot from this article (discovered on HN I think): What's so hard about PDF text extraction? https://www.filingdb.com/pdf-text-extraction In a nutshell, PDF is fundamentally different than MS Word: it's a standard for visual layout, without notions of paragraphs or even words. As OP said, it doesn't mean the tool is useless. It could quite often come handy for myself.

One of the weirdest things I've seen is a PDF where the text is complete gibberish if you copy paste, but perfect if you export it to HTML or Word in Acrobat. Never figured out how or why that might happen.

seen that happen quite often with LaTeX documents!

Re: Show HN: I made a simple PDF text editor

#70
post #58

So it claims to > Edit pdf like a word doc while preserving structure and format. While I'm sure there are cases where this works pretty well and can be very useful, it may be worth noting that -- just like every other tool in this space -- there will be many PDFs where it simply can't work. It'll be hugely dependent on exactly how the PDF-generating application/tool went about things. One simple example: suppose you…

Finding a font that matches the look of letters in the vicinity of the edit on Google Fonts or similar and embedding the missing characters from that font seems doable and should work pretty well.

Figuring out more global properties like multi-column layouts and reflowing text is a much harder problem.

Post reply on HN