Live data from Hacker News

Air Force 'rods from god' kinetic weapon could hit with nuclear-weapon force

businessinsider.com

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: Air Force 'rods from god' kinetic weapon could hit with nuclear-weapon force

#61
post #54
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the moon, you don’t need high quality weapons; you can compensate by increasing mass. And that moon base could become independ3nt because of its ability to launch rocks ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Moon_Is_a_Harsh_Mistress... )

Independence requires more than the ability to “drop rocks” it requires total self-sufficiency. Without that you’re bombing the people who can kill you just by withholding essentials like food, water, and air. No one is even pretending that a colony on the moon or Mars could be self-sufficient to thst degree with anything like our current technology.

No village or small city is self-supporting nowadays. Why would a moon base of similar size be different?

What matters is whether enough money flows in to buy elsewhere what you can’t produce.

If (a big if, but an assumption in Heinlein’s novel) a moon base can be made profitable, and kids get born there, so that people end up thinking of themselves as citizens of them moon, would it be fair if most of those profits keep ending up on earth?

In Heinlein’s novel, the idea is not that those living permanently on the moon bomb those on earth (even though that does happen), but that they use the threat of bombing them to get a fairer deal.

Re: Air Force 'rods from god' kinetic weapon could hit with nuclear-weapon force

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Guessing by lethal shockwaves are from relatively small explosions (like packets of C4), I'm going to go ahead and guess the energy dispersed from this would easily shatter all the concrete of the bunker and instantly kill anything living.

Maybe, but I'm not convinced. With enough velocity, a ping pong ball can blow a clean neat circular hole straight through a ping pong paddle. Fast moving objects can cause extremely localized damage. On the other hand if you shoot a fast at a plastic jug full of water, an incompressible fluid, it will shred the water jug specifically because that water is incompressible. Fill the jug with air or sand and you'll then…

Your ping pong ball example is fairly counter to everything I've ever seen but I'm no physicist. I would be very surprised if there's any velocity that would put the ball through the paddle without completely destroying both
Post reply on HN