Live data from Hacker News

Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

cbc.ca

61–70 of 140 posts

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#61
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed - I still use it (among others) more or less any time I'm looking for flights. It was tomhoward's cofounder Fenn Bailey that also first introduced me to "microcaching" with nginx via some blog post many years back, a trick which has been of much use over the years.

Awesome, great to hear! That micro-caching trick was so cool. It wasn't actually for Adioso, but for the Falls Festival, a huge New Years Eve outdoor music festival here in Australia. The coolest application we heard about for that technique was when Google did a doodle for Robert Moog's 78th Birthday [1], and the Moog company's humble little website got hammered. [1] https://www.google.com/doodles/robert-moogs-78th-…

Ha, found (via the wayback machine) the original article[1] and also an HN discussion about it back then too[2]. Fenn didn't mention who it was for, "just some friends" - I guess I figured out the connection and linked it to Adioso in my memory.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20111014232647/http://fennb.com/... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3109283

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#62
post #56

Passengers would stop complaining or even start volunteering if Air Canada was offering them a monetary compensation for postponing their trip to the next flight. This is what happens in Europe and getting 300€ to wait 4 hours in an airport is not too bad if you're not in a hurry.

Thanks for making this clear. In the EU, I've been asked multiple times if I'm OK with flying on the next day. 300€ / 600€ (if +1500km) and a nice hotel are quite nice as a student. Never understood why overbooking is considered annoying in the US.

Because Canadians don't get that. We get a $25 meal voucher and a ticket on the next flight.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#63
post #52

It's been discussed on HN before [1], but it's worth mentioning in this thread that there's a YC-backed company – Volantio – working to solve this specific problem. Most airlines' position is that they have to oversell flights, otherwise planes will fly with empty seats unnecessarily. But from passengers' point of view, there aren't always enough people who'll voluntarily accept an offer to transfer to a different fl…

> Most airlines' position is that they have to oversell flights, otherwise planes will fly with empty seats unnecessarily. With most fares nowadays being non-refundable, why should the airlines care whether the seat is empty or not? It's paid for. If it's empty, that's a bonus because they save a little bit of fuel, time at the gate, and the passengers adjacent to the empty seat have a better experience. Empty seats…

Because if a seat is sold twice but only used one that's more profit than if every seat is only sold once. Most businesses maximise profits, not passenger experience (and those that work on passenger experience do so because they've decided that's their way to increase profits and they'll do so in a cost effective way).

Airlines say that this means all the seats on a flight can be a bit cheaper as the cost of operating the flight is shared amongst more people but I'm skeptical of that. Businesses like free money and only pass that on as lower prices due to competition when they really have to.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#64
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Most airlines' position is that they have to oversell flights, otherwise planes will fly with empty seats unnecessarily. With most fares nowadays being non-refundable, why should the airlines care whether the seat is empty or not? It's paid for. If it's empty, that's a bonus because they save a little bit of fuel, time at the gate, and the passengers adjacent to the empty seat have a better experience. Empty seats…

If they know the s’est is going to be empty, they can sell it again.

Sure. The problem is that they sell it again without knowing that it's going to be empty.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#65
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Most airlines' position is that they have to oversell flights, otherwise planes will fly with empty seats unnecessarily. With most fares nowadays being non-refundable, why should the airlines care whether the seat is empty or not? It's paid for. If it's empty, that's a bonus because they save a little bit of fuel, time at the gate, and the passengers adjacent to the empty seat have a better experience. Empty seats…

Because if a seat is sold twice but only used one that's more profit than if every seat is only sold once. Most businesses maximise profits, not passenger experience (and those that work on passenger experience do so because they've decided that's their way to increase profits and they'll do so in a cost effective way). Airlines say that this means all the seats on a flight can be a bit cheaper as the cost of operati…

> Because if a seat is sold twice but only used one that's more profit than if every seat is only sold once.

Well, yeah, but that badly misses the point. Selling any product twice is more profitable than selling it only once, all else being equal. But in most industries, selling the same product twice is considered unacceptable. In fact, it would be considered fraud. The story that the airlines tell to make people think it should be acceptable in their industry is clearly bogus.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#66
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> there is sometime about compensation if they can't get you on a flight within X number of hours as a result of the fault of the airline EU air passenger rights https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-right...

Do these apply? Iceland isn’t in EU.

The EU rules apply to Iceland.

The reason is that Iceland is in the EEA. Part of the rules for having free access to the market is that Iceland has to accept EU rules. Basically they get all of the regulations but have no seat at the table. Norway is in the same boat.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#67
Is this only a North American thing? I've flown hundreds of times within Europe over the last few years, and every single time I've had a seat assigned at online check in, usually 24-72hrs before boarding depending on airline.

I've seen lines of standby passengers at Frankfurt, waiting at the gate just in case they get lucky at the last minute, but knowing in advance that they don't have a seat on that plane unless somebody else fails to turn up; and I'd assumed that the European carriers probably do overbook but manage it at check in time; I've never seen or heard of anyone ever getting turned away at the gate when they already had a boarding pass.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's just a description of overselling. What's unique to Air Canada about this story? Do the other airlines do this too?

Service staff appear to not make it clear to customers that unless your boarding pass has a seat number on it that you don't have a seat.

No airline I have ever flown with has ever made this clear to me.

Ever.

Maybe if you know what magic words to ask, and specifically ask them - but at that point, you should already know the answer.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#69
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because if a seat is sold twice but only used one that's more profit than if every seat is only sold once. Most businesses maximise profits, not passenger experience (and those that work on passenger experience do so because they've decided that's their way to increase profits and they'll do so in a cost effective way). Airlines say that this means all the seats on a flight can be a bit cheaper as the cost of operati…

> Because if a seat is sold twice but only used one that's more profit than if every seat is only sold once. Well, yeah, but that badly misses the point. Selling any product twice is more profitable than selling it only once, all else being equal. But in most industries, selling the same product twice is considered unacceptable. In fact, it would be considered fraud. The story that the airlines tell to make people th…

One valid reason for this practice is the existence of fully flexible fares, that can be switched at late notice. So there is always some uncertainty about exactly how many ticket holders will be wanting to board a given flight.

As for the rest, I dunno, maybe give them a break. Margins run at about 1%, give or take, so two empty seats matters. Heavy financial losses and bankruptcies are common for airlines.

On the practical side, people like to get to their destinations at their preferred time, so it’s good that airlines try and serve people by getting as many people as possible onto their preferred flight. And for environmental reasons people like to know that capacity/fuel isn’t being wasted.

Having worked with airlines for a long time, I’m no great lover of their business practices, but on this topic we can do a bit better than just presuming them to be greedy, exploitative monsters.

Re: Air Canada agents reveal overselling practices

#70
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> there is sometime about compensation if they can't get you on a flight within X number of hours as a result of the fault of the airline EU air passenger rights https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-right...

Do these apply? Iceland isn’t in EU.

The site addresses this pretty well at almost the top of the page:

- If your flight is within the EU and is operated either by an EU or a non-EU airline

- If your flight arrives in the EU from outside the EU and is operated by an EU airline

- If your flight departs from the EU to a non-EU country operated by an EU or a non-EU airline

- If you have not already received benefits (compensation, re-routing, assistance from the airline) for flight related problems for this journey under the relevant law of a non-EU country.

So pretty much all flights departing from within the EU is covered.

Post reply on HN