Live data from Hacker News

“Write Drunk, Edit Sober” Is Bad Advice

goinswriter.com

61–64 of 64 posts

Re: “Write Drunk, Edit Sober” Is Bad Advice

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The internet in a freaking nutshell, I'm so not going to miss that part once this pile of crap tips over.

How is the internet "tipping over" going to change what's fundamentally human? Changing the interpretation of what someone said to fit your argument can be seen on the school playground and in Plato's Gorgias. It's not going away anytime soon. Agreeing on an interpretation is the first step to conceiving an argument. Wrestling through this is a big part of having a discussion, and someone can always try to unfairly a…

So basically you're saying you hate charities.

Re: “Write Drunk, Edit Sober” Is Bad Advice

#62
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taking things too literally seems to be a plague infecting many topics lately. I've interpreted the phrase similarly, do whatever you need to, just get "it" out of your head! Perfection is the enemy of good.

This reminds me of the recent poster PETA put out. It asks people to say "feed 2 birds with one scone" instead of the familiar version. haha

I would have thought PETA would be all in favour of efficiently putting down animals. >.>

Re: “Write Drunk, Edit Sober” Is Bad Advice

#63

Has this guy ever actually done any creative writing, or just written advice books? There is a definite use for getting mildly buzzed as part of the creative process. Alcohol makes it easier to turn off the part of your brain that demands perfection and get a lot of stuff that may not be great but can be fixed rather than slowly trying to make one perfect sentence after another. Weed is great for when you need to sit…

I'm a professional sculptress who makes math and physics visualizations, weed is indispensable to my creative process for exactly the reasons you described. It helps me get into that state of flow faster, helps me better visualize abstract concepts and figure out how to translate them into physical objects, makes the boring repetitive parts more fun, and it helps me find more novel and interesting solutions to different construction problems I encounter. I never get stoned, just buzzed, because if I get stoned then I can't do anything. And I really only smoke when I'm sitting down to get to work, I'm not much of a recreational smoker at all. Weed is for business hours! If I just wanna have fun, I'm gonna drink beer.

Alcohol has a pretty negative effect on my work, though. I get sloppy and it's a terrible idea to play with sharp objects and permanent inks if you've been drinking anyway. Loosening up and being unafraid to make things I think might fail isn't something I really struggle with because my creative process is super iterative and experimental. That one Ira Glass quote made me realize the power of full-on wallowing in and relishing the ugly prototype stages of things, so I do a lot of that knowing that after a few different versions to work out the kinks and try some different approaches, I'll have something really good on my hands. I love putting a final sculpture beside the ugly prototype it began as and seeing how far it evolved, it's like looking at a baby picture beside a picture of the successful, well-adjusted adult the baby grew up to be. I can't help but take pride in both of them!

Re: “Write Drunk, Edit Sober” Is Bad Advice

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The internet in a freaking nutshell, I'm so not going to miss that part once this pile of crap tips over.

How is the internet "tipping over" going to change what's fundamentally human? Changing the interpretation of what someone said to fit your argument can be seen on the school playground and in Plato's Gorgias. It's not going away anytime soon. Agreeing on an interpretation is the first step to conceiving an argument. Wrestling through this is a big part of having a discussion, and someone can always try to unfairly a…

I would be very, very careful about assuming that any observed behaviors are fundamentally human. Leave people alone to do their thing and you would get an entirely different set of behaviors. There's no question that the internet amplifies our worst tendencies, with a little help from the psychopaths on top of the big tech pyramid. It will tip over, because it's not viable in the long term.
Post reply on HN