Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk: The Recode interview

recode.net

61–70 of 71 posts

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I think people find this kind of backed-up braggadocio incredibly entertaining and exciting to watch, it makes Elon musk an irresistible personality to follow. I can only speak for myself but yes, exactly this. Didn't they model the movie Tony Stark after him? I like that character for the same reason; he's confident, he's cocky, he does what he wants, he doesn't really care what others think, he's not afraid to off…

> Didn't they model the movie Tony Stark after him? Iron Man the character was created in 1963. Elon Musk was born in 1971. The actor of Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr) did say in 2011 he was inspired in part by Elon Musk when developing his character, but that was 7 years ago now and certainly predates some of Elon Musk's more notorious antics. We all certainly cross the line and should be forgiven for it, but the stand…

interweaved feeback loops between the two maybe

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He's the CEO of one of the most valuable car companies and the words he speaks affect those trading on that information. Saying whatever he wants for entertainment is horribly irresponsible when his words have financial consequences for real people. The "funding secured" tweet wasn't harmless, it was a lie that gave a false valuation basis for Tesla at $420. If he was just an employee or outsider that wouldn't matter…

Unpopular opinion but I’m coming up pretty short on sympathy for someone trading stocks based on a few words in a tweet and then losing their shirt. These people are grownups and fully aware of the risks they are taking when they walk into the casino. Nobody is forcing them to read twitter or take it seriously as a source of investment advice. The $420 thing didn’t hurt grandma’s pension fund or long term buy-and-hol…

You don't want to live in a world where corporate officers of publicly traded companies can make completely false statements about funding events without severe consequences.

You really just don't actually want that.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#63
post #8

Kara Swisher is a terrible interviewer. She was terrible here [1], and she was terrible in this interview. You have an hour with Elon Musk and you ask what BFR means again (knowing the answer) and don't know that they attempt to catch fairings? Why does she always look like she did not do her research? Why do I never learn anything new if she interviews? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsixsRI-Sz4

I personally think both of the RECODE interviewers (don't know their names) try to be a little too cool for school when interviewing these once-a-generation people.

Your reaction is understandable. It's obvious Kara prides herself on being a grouch and a hard-ass. I remember thinking the same during the D5 interview with Steve Jobs, where she mouthed off to the point that Mossberg shushed her.

In retrospect, I've changed my mind. It isn't healthy for an industry to only have reporters who softball every interview, who just parrot crap from press releases. In tech, that's close to what we have. It's allowed companies to get away with a lot of shady nonsense.

So these days I'm really thankful that tech has a Kara Swisher.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#64
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unpopular opinion but I’m coming up pretty short on sympathy for someone trading stocks based on a few words in a tweet and then losing their shirt. These people are grownups and fully aware of the risks they are taking when they walk into the casino. Nobody is forcing them to read twitter or take it seriously as a source of investment advice. The $420 thing didn’t hurt grandma’s pension fund or long term buy-and-hol…

You don't want to live in a world where corporate officers of publicly traded companies can make completely false statements about funding events without severe consequences. You really just don't actually want that.

Sure. But this can be dealt with via the legal system.

Do the thing, get fined (obviously we should set the fine high enough that it's more than a speed bump), sorted.

We don't want the thing to happen because it causes inefficiency in markets, bad outcomes, etc.

Moralizing it doesn't really serve a purpose.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#65
post #32

Joe Rogan interview of Elon is much better: https://youtu.be/ycPr5-27vSI

I don't agree. Rogan is a better interviewer but Elon is much more fluent in the recode interview.

Joe Rogan as interviewer but in the Tesla Palo Alto office instead of in the evening when Musk is tired would be perfect.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#67
post #5

I think the thing that people really like about Elon Musk is that he just doesn't care about the interpersonal social status dynamics at play with his position in the world. If you look at the interview, he's very dismissive of Kara's questioning about how others perceive him: Kara: What’s Twitter? Okay, let’s start with Twitter. I have an obsession with Twitter, too, and an addiction. What happens with you and Twitt…

>I think people find this kind of backed-up braggadocio incredibly entertaining and exciting to watch, it makes Elon musk an irresistible personality to follow. I can only speak for myself but yes, exactly this. Didn't they model the movie Tony Stark after him? I like that character for the same reason; he's confident, he's cocky, he does what he wants, he doesn't really care what others think, he's not afraid to off…

Howard Hughes Jr. is much more likely.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#68
post #27
post #21

I'm tired of having Elon Musk in my life. I like his initiatives, but Im very tired of him.

Why comment on him then?

I think I understand what 'ProAm' meant. Elon Musk is irresistible to nerds and geeks. He's the ultimate expression of the technical mind. And one wants Elon to be right all the time. He's like an addiction. You want to stop but it's not easy.

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#69
post #14
post #5

I think the thing that people really like about Elon Musk is that he just doesn't care about the interpersonal social status dynamics at play with his position in the world. If you look at the interview, he's very dismissive of Kara's questioning about how others perceive him: Kara: What’s Twitter? Okay, let’s start with Twitter. I have an obsession with Twitter, too, and an addiction. What happens with you and Twitt…

> I think people find this kind of backed-up braggadocio incredibly entertaining and exciting to watch, it makes Elon musk an irresistible personality to follow. I think they follow him because he created Tesla, Space-X and other things. Braggadocio without results to back it up won't take him as far.

tell that to the president of the united states

Re: Elon Musk: The Recode interview

#70

Kara Swisher is a terrible interviewer. She was terrible here [1], and she was terrible in this interview. You have an hour with Elon Musk and you ask what BFR means again (knowing the answer) and don't know that they attempt to catch fairings? Why does she always look like she did not do her research? Why do I never learn anything new if she interviews? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsixsRI-Sz4

Agreed. She always seems to me to be far more interested in herself than in the person she's interviewing. Previously I thought it was runaway narcissism, but I think you may have nailed it in saying she doesn't do her research. Perhaps everything is phrased as "Well when I did this...how does that relate to you", because she didn't prepare and is just vamping. (Good old Hanlon's Razor...)

She's done her research. She is trying to ask questions ordinary (more uninformed) people would ask.
Post reply on HN