Live data from Hacker News

VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

electrek.co

61–70 of 85 posts

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#61
post #38

Does anyone else think traditional manufacturers will initially sell their EV's at a loss or low profit margin to get a bigger foothold in the market, being propped up by their sales of diesel/petrol cars.

Possible, but is it really worth it if they don't have the infrastructure to back up their EV's?

Also, what will happen to the price of ICE cars if EV's start catching up?

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#62

I wish. I'd pay a lot if someone would make a good e-version of a "boring" car like a Golf. No huge center-mounted display, no app store, no forced remote updates, no DRM locking me out of reparing my own car. If they keep the sensors for partially automated driving as a better cruise control, I'm fine with that. Unfortunately, the current e-Golf is just a regular Golf poorly converted to electric, way too expensive…

Nissan Leaf, Renault Zoe, Chevy Bolt, and the list goes on -- all boring little EVs. The huge displays and app store are the exception, not the rule.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#63

I'm sure Tesla will also have EVs as good as Tesla for half the price by 2020. They'll also have a vastly improved super charger network, a mature software ecosystem, a mature direct sales/servicing model, and whatever else they dream up like Powerwall and other systems that can potentially add value to the whole. VW will just be scratching the surface by 2020 while Tesla will likely continue sprinting ahead.

When EV gets popular enough won't all petrol station install chargers too? When this happens the super charger network will not be a large advantage. The only issue I see is if each company creates it's own "super/fast" charging system and DRMs it for "security" reasons.

The best place to charge an EV is wherever the car spends the majority of its daylight hours (which for many workers will be the company parking lot). That way they can be charged directly from solar PV during the peak hours, avoiding the necessity for storing that energy anywhere else.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plot double twist: VW won't actually produce more or cheaper EVs but Tesla goes under and stops making cars so technically this statement is still correct.

Triple plot twist: VAG buys Tesla

Quadruple plot twist: Tesla buys VAG

(Being German VAG not succeeding is quite a frightening perspective. But being human I appreciate Musk jumpstarting the EV business, whoever will be the big players in the end.)

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#65
VW has enough problems with the quality of their ICE vehicles. They don't need to brag about quality of the relatively new electric vehicles.

If VWs electric vehicles really are as good as Tesla's by 2020, it will be more a condemnation of Tesla than praise for VW.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When EV gets popular enough won't all petrol station install chargers too? When this happens the super charger network will not be a large advantage. The only issue I see is if each company creates it's own "super/fast" charging system and DRMs it for "security" reasons.

The best place to charge an EV is wherever the car spends the majority of its daylight hours (which for many workers will be the company parking lot). That way they can be charged directly from solar PV during the peak hours, avoiding the necessity for storing that energy anywhere else.

Also, if these charging stations are managed by the power company, they can act as reserves of power for the area, so electricity spikes can be handled by EVs. This also goes for cars parked at home, which can charge after peak hours and use other renewable sources, like wind.

I'm very interested to see if this actually happens in the near future.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#67
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure but VW produces 10 Million a year. Tesla 100k. VW hast way more: experience, capacity, people, money. They can probably do that.

VW produces 10 million regular ICE cars a year. It will take time to shift an entire entrenched organizational culture to focus on EVs...and not just making them, but to make ones that are truly without compromise ("as good as Tesla"). These things aren't easy at all, though it might be tempting to think that it's just a matter of resources. Microsoft had all the resources in the world and still couldn't pull off Bin…

Microsoft did pull off Bing and Windows Phone technically, they just missed on making them popular. VW is already in the car market and has a substantial user-base, that wasn't the case for Microsoft in those markets.

If VW can launch a quality product with way more supply than Tesla, they'll sell more. Tesla is doing most of the marketing for EVs, VW and other auto makers just need to meet demand. There's far less customer loyalty on things like cars than computers or online services, so it'll come down to value.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#68
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tesla is a battery company.

And there’s the rub. From where are VW going to source their batteries? Having vertical integration rather than having to buy from third parties is a fairly substantial advantage.

WTF are you talking about? Tesla buys their batteries from a third party.

Re: VW CEO says they’ll have ‘EVs as good as Tesla’s for half the price by 2020’

#70
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Triple plot twist: VAG buys Tesla

Quadruple plot twist: Tesla buys VAG (Being German VAG not succeeding is quite a frightening perspective. But being human I appreciate Musk jumpstarting the EV business, whoever will be the big players in the end.)

Quintuple plot twist: Tesla attempts to buy VW, but ends up pulling a Porsche and getting bought by VW in the act.
Post reply on HN