Live data from Hacker News

Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

nytimes.com

61–70 of 174 posts

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#61
> Evidence suggests that these are mostly just attention-starved gamers looking to impress one another

What is the link with gaming I'm missing here? Is 4chan simply associated by gaming defacto? I don't see anything else about video games or any evidence of these people being gamers in the article...

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#62
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Being funny isn't really a defense against pointing out that it's harmful.

Is it?

Harmful? "a few of the accounts started posting misleading information about the midterm elections, including encouraging liberals to vote on Nov. 7". Yes.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#63
post #14

A long time ago, I was told "don't feed the trolls". It's hard to see how this publicity (e.g. the NYT) is not feeding the trolls. There is no doubt that this campaign, whatever motivations, was successful. At the same time, social media platforms are more at the ready to ban pranksters, bots, etc. That might be the only approach that works when the majority of society participates. (1) don't feed the troll, but it g…

You're completely correct. Don't feed the trolls is exactly right. And yet every single time that the right throws out some more bait, no matter how silly, no matter how stupid, the left looses it's shit.

Take this NPC thing, it's a damn joke, just like every single meme - it may be funny, it may not be depending on your own preferences, but when it gets posted and in response you have 50 articles the next day about how it 'dehumanises' something or other ... before it even gets to NYT, the trolls are more than fed.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#64
post #15
post #7

...as someone who is oblivious to these things (only knew it was a "thing" last night)...can someone explain why this is harmful and not just people wasting time?

It's basically propaganda. Propaganda is generally agreed to be a bad thing for a true democracy.

Propaganda for what?

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#65

I love the last question ‘Aren’t you giving these trolls the attention they’re seeking by writing about them in The New York Times?’ I thought the same thing. Interesting to see right-wing business coming out of *chan-land. I’d always seen it as more of a left-wing place.

*chan-land is pro freedom of speech. Historically that meant being against things like religious crusades against explicit lyrics and anti-evolution arguments. With the shift of the left against free speech, they've become the new enemy.

No they're not, their idea of freedom of speech extends no further than "I want to say whatever I want."

Their longstanding history of doxxing, conducting raids, etc. on those who they disagree with are the exact opposite of actual proponents of free speech.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#66
post #61

> Evidence suggests that these are mostly just attention-starved gamers looking to impress one another What is the link with gaming I'm missing here? Is 4chan simply associated by gaming defacto? I don't see anything else about video games or any evidence of these people being gamers in the article...

Maybe they think that only gamers know what an "NPC" is. But, feels like a stretch.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#67
post #3

The speed at which the media have rounded against this meme is breathtaking. Are some memes inherently powerful and just need to be controlled? Why are they powerful? How much longer can 30 year old boomers be let sip Monsters outdoors? It's not right.

siiiippp

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#68
post #41

Evan James has a good writeup on the sort of anxieties around society that sprung up the NPC meme [0]. There's a portion which I think has a kernel of truth, although it is definitely generous to the kind of people that immaturely lashed out and made very low-effort twitter accounts which wound up propagating the meme: >The far right can be profoundly intuitive creatures, who feel more deeply than cursory glances sug…

It confuses me, because "don't take things at face value" and "don't just follow a script" is, well, postmodernism. It's also anticapitalism. It's also a commentary about peoples reverence of traditional gender roles and religions. Actually, I totally fail to see why it's a conservative meme at all, unless it's being repeated without any attempt to consider broader implications.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#69
Banned for "voter suppression"? Really?

As if a bunch of people are going to get disenfranchised because a stupid joke tweet? Come on. If you don't vote because of that one tweet maybe you aren't educated enough to be voting in the first place.

Furthermore, why not just ban that one tweet? Banning the entire meme because one tweet only goes to further the narrative that anything right wing is being systematically suppressed on the internet.

Congrats on throwing the trolls a giant hunk of red meat, Twitter.

Re: Twitter has barred hundreds of accounts for posing as liberal activists

#70
post #24

Not sure how to feel about this one. Waiting for John Oliver's take.

I'm with you on that. Eagerly waiting to be fed my opinion and then post about it on FB and Twitter. My friends are going to love it and I will feel appreciated.
Post reply on HN