Live data from Hacker News

Italy opens probe into Ryanair hand luggage charges

bbc.co.uk

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: Italy opens probe into Ryanair hand luggage charges

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Weight is largely irrelevant. The difference between a airliner full of 45Kg people versus 90Kg people constitutes about 5% of the total plane weight. Some fuel savings but would not be worth the aggravation, client humiliation, lawsuits etc. What it boils down to is volume and time. A passenger takes up a seat regardless of how large he is (...) so he's charged for a seat. Luggage changes that equation far more than…

> A passenger takes up a seat regardless of how large he is I'm only halfway joking when I say I've lost many an elbow into the side of someone substantially larger than I. For some "a seat" is "their seat + several inches of mine". I know it's not really the problem at hand, but it's poor proxy for volume, and again, just shows that the weight fee is just a sham. Just going to start manufacturing a "flight jacket" w…

> Just going to start manufacturing a "flight jacket" with pockets for all your luggage...

Already there...

https://www.skyscanner.net/news/best-wearable-luggage-jacket...

Re: Italy opens probe into Ryanair hand luggage charges

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So how far and for how long do you think someone can fly with a luggage that fits under their seat? I can't speak for everyone (and are probably an exception, since even for a 3 week vacation my luggage never exceeds 15kg). But I can easily go for a very long weekend (up to a week) with the contents of a small duffle bag that easily fits under the seat. Which means a fresh t-shirt, underwear and socks for the entire…

I agree this is doable for a long weekend, but that's if you take only that and you have everything in one bag. Seems more of an edge case than the standard. Especially with limitation of liquids in handbags.

The biggest promotion on https://www.ryanair.com/ as I see it is "Two-night stays in Europe from €88" — weekend trips are a big part of Ryanair's business.

A toothpaste tube, deodourant and a mini shaving foam fit easily in the 1L limit.

Re: Italy opens probe into Ryanair hand luggage charges

#63
post #8

Not sure how I feel about this. It annoyed my greatly on my last RyanAir flight that in order to take a slightly larger than laptop sized bag (35L) I had to pay for priority which was 8 quid or whatever. A Primera flight I've just booked is now doing exactly the same. Small bag free, bigger bag not so. But, as some of the comments here, I think it sped things up once on the plane. However, adding the extra charge lea…

I'd say this is an open problem in the metasearch space right now. Airlines are increasingly splitting out what you do and don't get with your ticket into different fare classes, which they brand and line item themselves, making it difficult for a typical traveler to make heads or tails of whether they do or do not get a cabin bag or complimentary meal, etc.
Post reply on HN