Live data from Hacker News

Why I Don't Buy Organic, and Why You Might Not Want to Either

forbes.com

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: Why I Don't Buy Organic, and Why You Might Not Want to Either

#61
post #16

The author says .... "and the actual pesticides used today are mostly relatively non-toxic to humans." Nothing can be further from the truth. Most (in fact all) pesticides used are designed to kill biological cells. So pesticides do not distinguish between a caterpillars cell or a humans. All pesticides are harmful to humans, some in tiny doses, some in large doses. FYI - Landmark lawsuit claims Monsanto hid dangers…

> Most (in fact all) pesticides used are designed to kill biological cells

You can make pesticides based on hormones of the target insect. Those pesticides do not kill cells.

Insects are kind of like little biological state machines, with hormones controlling the state transitions. A pesticide based on those hormones can mess up the timing. For instance, suppose you have in insect the munches on your crops all summer, then when it gets cooler and wetter lays its eggs and dies, leaving the eggs to repeat the cycle next year. A hormone-based pesticide might be able to make them lay the eggs early, when it is too warm and dry for the eggs to survive and when things that might eat the eggs are active.

Re: Why I Don't Buy Organic, and Why You Might Not Want to Either

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I don't want to eat food that has been sprayed with chemicals over and over again to kill the various predators to that plant. That would be a good reason to consider conventional. Both organic and conventional farms use pesticides. But, by restricting themselves to only pesticides that a program within the USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service has deemed are sufficiently "natural" (not safe, not effective, not env…

Does anybody really think the organic marketing makes sense in the first place ? I hope not, but I guess you're mostly right and people don't see this for some reason.

Organic marketing is the result of our education system failing to properly educate our populace on chemistry and the marketing taking advantage of the failure. When you go to a conventional farm you can see the exact chemicals sprayed onto the crops in a precise manner, there are GPS programs to correctly allocate based on prior science efforts. Then someone noted that isolated chemicals were not natural and stated that natural was better for you; not questioning why spreading manure instead of the chemical necessary was better (which the manure now runs off and causes issues like when we did not have the agri stewardship we have today).

Organic marketing works because decision makers lack the critical thinking to question the efficacy difference. This being said, there is a difference in taste between and organic red delicious and conventionally grown red delicious.

Post reply on HN