Live data from Hacker News

Yam, cultivate and cook

primitivetechnology.wordpress.com

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#61

A tip: turn on captions. The creator somewhat famously doesn't talk, but does provide really informative captions for each step of the build/experiment process. Related: if you like this and want more I recently read a book series called Bonesetter that has a protagonist who lives in primitive times and it tells the story of a person kicked from their tribe, but who prospers by building Primitive Technology type inve…

I had no idea, thanks for the tip!

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#62
post #25

> This form of farming is a good way to get around the conventional farming practice of clearing trees to make fields. Yeah, you harvested two yams (less than a day's calories) over a six month period. That doesn't scale up the way modern farming practices do.

More to the point, the effort that went into making the enclosure was probably 2000+ calories--more than the yams inside. I think early horticulture is basically: Plant edible food with minimal fuss, and eat what comes up. If wild pigs show up, well, free protein.

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#63
post #4

There's a lot of sophistication in "primitive" agriculture. Humans have always been as intelligent and ambitious as they are today; they just didn't always have today's tools. Yams always make me think of Gone with the Wind . The climax of Act III (not labeled as such, but stories are stories) is Scarlett O'Hara at her family's plantation. Yankee soldiers have come through and taken every scrap of food, but they didn…

Does anyone have an idea when these procedures by humans could have been done? The techniques this guy used could have been done 7000bc? (Super recent) They look advanced requiring: passed down knowledge, seasons knowledge, plant knowledge, fire creation, pot making etc. Doing this would have also created villages since you need to stick around to tend plots of land - which would have invited attacks from other tribe…

The earliest clear evidence of the cultivation of crops is about 11,000 years old. The Pre-Pottery Neolithic A culture of the Levant lived in small mud-brick huts and had purpose-built granaries.

http://www.pnas.org/content/106/27/10966.long

Analysis of stone tools suggests that a wide range starchy foods were being systematically gathered and prepared for much of the Middle Stone Age (~280,000 BP to ~25,000 BP) although it is unclear whether these foods were being actively cultivated.

http://www.academia.edu/426173/Middle_Stone_Age_Starch_Acqui...

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How's that? Hard to refine? I did hear elsewhere that aluminium is one of the most common metals on the world, possibly even moreso than iron.

Made with electrolysis of a molten aluminum salt. Requires a lot of electricity. Back in the 1850s they made it with expensive chemical reactions and the french elite used to wear it as jewellery.

I've read the real thing was to have aluminium cutlery.

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#65
post #60

A tip: turn on captions. The creator somewhat famously doesn't talk, but does provide really informative captions for each step of the build/experiment process. Related: if you like this and want more I recently read a book series called Bonesetter that has a protagonist who lives in primitive times and it tells the story of a person kicked from their tribe, but who prospers by building Primitive Technology type inve…

Another tip: watch it once without the captions, then again with them. There's more 'wonder' this way.

Would also recommend. I watched nearly all of these videos without captions when I first came across the channel before I realized there were captions.

It's fun to "play along at home" and try to figure out why he's doing something without the captions.

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#66

What a great idea, to feature this fellow's Primitive Technology blog (and his outstanding Youtube channel) here on a high tech news site. Fire making, clay pots, mud huts, stone axes, rope, hunting weapons -- these are what kept people alive for eons, and ironically in our modern high tech era, many if not most of these skills are largely forgotten by all but a few remaining primitive tribes and archivists like him.…

I think it is interesting to reflect on the idea that high technology builds on top of primitive technology. Just as he uses past tools to make more complex tools, every human era of technology builds upon the last. You could say primitive stone tools are in the recipe for developing an ICBM or a semiconductor if you go back far enough.

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#69
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, I was commenting specifically on this claim: > This form of farming is a good way to get around the conventional farming practice of clearing trees to make fields. It's not a good form of farming, because it's both low density and expensive.

Depends on your criteria. If you only aim to feed a small group, it is significantly less cost to make a handful of enclosures than to clear a large amount of space for a field, even if the field is more efficient at scale.

In my country, we grow yams pretty frequently in the villages and despite being low density, subsistence farming, people still clear land. It's basically impossible to live off the land by farming without clearing away trees.

Re: Yam, cultivate and cook

#70
post #46

I stumbled on his videos a couple of months ago. Sadly, I only realized yesterday that there were captions that described his process, but watching it without isn't too bad either. He does things in a very evident manner and it's pretty relaxing just watching him do his thing.

I prefer without captions, it's more relaxing and I'm not planning to replicate the feats anyway. :)
Post reply on HN