Live data from Hacker News

Einstein's travel diaries reveal attitudes towards people he met in Asia

theguardian.com

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: Einstein's travel diaries reveal attitudes towards people he met in Asia

#61

Why is it so "shocking"? Discussing racial differences was more common in his time, and being a great scientist does not necessarily coincide with general wisdom. I hope this story will help people realize that we should not ban the work of people who have said problematic things.

Ron Paul, for example.

Re: Einstein's travel diaries reveal attitudes towards people he met in Asia

#62
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If racism were subjective, we wouldn't ban it in the public scope as there would be no clear standard for anyone to follow in their self-censorship. Racism should reflect an attribute that can be factually proven---intelligence, strength, moral character at birth, etc. It should not reflect a totally subjective physical attribute like beauty.

I've never heard your definition of racism ("attributes that can be factually proven"?). In my experience, racism is subjective and every rationalization is done afterwards. How often have you heard of someone convincing an avowed racist of anything based on arguments? "I've always thought were dumb, weak, morally bankrupt, and have brought decadence to our country, but now that I look at this scientific study I'm co…

Every racist position I have ever heard of has been defanged by the truth, and proof. Racism is not bad because it makes you feel bad, it is bad because it is demonstrably untrue and basing your society on the bedrock of racist lies is simply shooting yourself in the foot.

I don't know why you disagree.

Do you think racist views are true, but we should ignore them out of political correctness?

Post reply on HN