Live data from Hacker News

Chess boxing

en.wikipedia.org

61–70 of 118 posts

Re: Chess boxing

#61

I like playing chess and working out. So I combined chess and workouts. There are several variations, * Do X crunches every 2 or 3 moves. * Do X pushups/pullups/situps/skipping/etc every 2 or 3 moves. Disclaimer: I am also creator or a chess variation halfchess.com

What a great game! I lost of course. I like that it makes the next game easier, and that you can play with eight or ten pieces.

Did you try with six?

Re: Chess boxing

#62
post #10

I thought I might be good at chessboxing until I saw the champion. http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/84863-World-Chess-...

.... of course the champ is Russian. Seriously, the only way this sport could be more Russian would be if they somehow added a vodka-drinking contest round.

And you have to play the chess round while squatting.

Re: Chess boxing

#63
This is cute, but with what we now know about CTE, I can't help but find boxing, football, etc disgusting.

I'm not just being a pretentious nerd, I actually like sports and I used to love watching boxing / MMA.

It is so so so much worse than what we thought. Dave Mirra, Chris Benoit, Aaron Hernandez, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NFL_players_with_chron...

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/07/25/sports/footba...

Re: Chess boxing

#64

I like playing chess and working out. So I combined chess and workouts. There are several variations, * Do X crunches every 2 or 3 moves. * Do X pushups/pullups/situps/skipping/etc every 2 or 3 moves. Disclaimer: I am also creator or a chess variation halfchess.com

What a great game! I lost of course. I like that it makes the next game easier, and that you can play with eight or ten pieces. Did you try with six?

No I didn't try with six pieces. :-) Thanks for the like. I am working on a two player version that connects random people to play against each other for the next version.

Re: Chess boxing

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Getting used to boxing means you get used to seeing violence and it doesn't hurt so much any more. I practiced thai boxing for many years and it may sound odd, but I don't really see boxing as a violent sport, no more than let say soccer. I've never hit anyone (other than on a ring) and never will, and I hate violence as much as most people. In the context of boxing I see hitting as a technical move. Besides the oc…

Isn't thai-boxing like Karate or fencing where you stop before you actually hurt the opponent, having shown that you could do it? Whereas in boxing there is no such conception of stopping before you actually hit. Does boxing cause brain damage? This article says: "Almost certainly": https://www.livescience.com/1519-boxing-brain-damage.html

While muay thai does have point scoring, it is more like boxing where you score points for landing a damaging technique and do not stop on a point being scored. Funnily enough punches often do not score unless they cause considerable movement of the opponent as they are seen as less damaging than a kick, knee or elbow.

One area that is different to a lot of other sports is that fights aren't stopped for bleeding often as it is very common for thai style elbows to open gashes on the face. A lot of experienced fighters will have scarring around the eyes from getting cut with elbows.

That said in the west fights are split into 3 classes (4 if you include novice fights) C which has no elbows or knees to the head, B which has no elbows to the head and A which uses All legal thai techniques

Re: Chess boxing

#66
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In fact, competitive chess requires adapting a very merciless mindset and swapping empathy for "killer instinct". In one interview - with Peter Thiel, by the way - current WC Magnus Carlsen was asked about Josh Waitzkin. (Waitzkin is a fairly well known and highly talented chess player, whose biography inspired the movie "Searching for Bobby Fischer". He's left chess for martial arts since.) Carlsen half-jokingly sai…

You are right chess can be harmful too. Those wasted hours studying and memorizing start-games and end-games and then as you say the hatred. Maybe it's good mental exercise but you might better use your time studying mathematics physics science or engineering and that way help yourself and others better.

Well I'm not exactly saying that (it sure might be, like anything that can consume your life)...

My tongue-in-cheek point was along the lines that just because a discipline doesn't involve punching someone in the face - unlike boxing, called out for it by the parent comment - doesn't necessarily mean it's not a brutal sport... in psychological dimension, obviously.

Re: Chess boxing

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't thai-boxing like Karate or fencing where you stop before you actually hurt the opponent, having shown that you could do it? Whereas in boxing there is no such conception of stopping before you actually hit. Does boxing cause brain damage? This article says: "Almost certainly": https://www.livescience.com/1519-boxing-brain-damage.html

No, Thai boxing or Muay Thai is not a point fighting sport. There are knock outs. Kicks, knees, and elbows are allowed. There's also forms of karate that allow full contact.

I boxed twice as an amateur, and got stopped in my second fight after my eye closed up (southpaw got a thumb in my eye is my excuse).

But I look at Thai Boxing matches with flying knees, elbows, etc and that recent video where a fighter footswept someone and then kneed them in the head on the way down and I think "Fuck that."

Re: Chess boxing

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I play chess and have boxed and done martial arts, although never together in the same ring. I found chess more destructive than boxing — it serves little to no cardiovascular benefit, and can be hugely addictive. (Bullet chess and competition play can readily take over your life, and I've seen careers and relationships destroyed by it.) The fittest people I've ever met have been boxers. Yes, the risk of head trauma…

Right getting hit still hurts, but seeing somebody else get hit does not hurt so bad, once you start paying to go to see a boxing match. I'm not REALLY against boxing let people do what they want to do. But I think the viewpoint that it idolizes knocking other people out is worth bringing into the discussion. Ali was the greatest but even he suffered brain damage because of boxing I believe. And then Tyson was the gr…

Do you think Tyson was violent outside the ring because of boxing? I think due to his upbringing and history before boxing, I don't think it is the boxing to blame.

Re: Chess boxing

#69
I've seen a few chessboxing matches. The thing about boxing is that it's very rare to end by KO (especially at the level of your typical chess-boxer), so it would normally be decided on points. However, because it's speed chess they're playing, and adrenaline is high, it's fairly hard to get all the way to the final round without a checkmate.

So every single match I've seen has been won by the better chess player, and the boxing has just been an interesting diversion.

Re: Chess boxing

#70
post #63

This is cute, but with what we now know about CTE, I can't help but find boxing, football, etc disgusting. I'm not just being a pretentious nerd, I actually like sports and I used to love watching boxing / MMA. It is so so so much worse than what we thought. Dave Mirra, Chris Benoit, Aaron Hernandez, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NFL_players_with_chron... https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/07/25/sports/…

Even without the long-term damage associated with CTE, there is limited intellectual value to any sport that involves hitting others in the head.
Post reply on HN