Live data from Hacker News

Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

old.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 184 posts

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That feature reminds me of what they had in Logan's Run. A lot of stuff feels like people trying to implement an idea from one of their fav sci-fi books or movies.

The part where at 30 you're deemed useless to society?

That definitely sounds like Tinder to me.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#62

About "8. Dating". I think over last 10 years, online dating has not been solved at all. Here are typical problems which nearly all dating sites run into: 1. Women got way more attention than men. Such environment stimulates aggressive strategies on both sides. Men must spend a lot of effort to reach as many women as possible. Women must filter out males as hard as possible. Men are discouraged to carefully read prof…

For your point #1, the reason you have this problem is ultimately supply and demand. There's certain subsets of demographics that are highly uneven due to many factors: 1 of which is that men date younger women, hence women in greater demand than younger men, and older men in greater demand than older women, etc. A dating site won't be able to fix this.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#63
post #58
post #46

My take (just the first five): 1. A cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom. Spotify & Apple Music. Pay $10/mo for unlimited access to most music. Took the wind out of music piracy. (TV & film are undergoing a similar transition to subscription models, more slowly.) 2. Simplified browsing...Grandparents and small children don't want the full web... Apps. Remember this list is from just one year after the…

> 3. New news. NY Times topped $1 billion in subscription revenue last year. Quite a feat and definitely an indication that money is to be made in digital news. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/08/business/new-york-times-c...

The question is whether that's zero-sum consolidation (as competitors close) or sustainable.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#64
post #46

My take (just the first five): 1. A cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom. Spotify & Apple Music. Pay $10/mo for unlimited access to most music. Took the wind out of music piracy. (TV & film are undergoing a similar transition to subscription models, more slowly.) 2. Simplified browsing...Grandparents and small children don't want the full web... Apps. Remember this list is from just one year after the…

> 3. New news.

For this one, I would definitely say Twitter. As an example, my first info about the recent school shooting in Florida was a tweet by a scared student. Anything that happens anywhere in the world will spread on Twitter literally in an instant, and the same goes for non-realtime content published elsewhere.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#65
post #46

My take (just the first five): 1. A cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom. Spotify & Apple Music. Pay $10/mo for unlimited access to most music. Took the wind out of music piracy. (TV & film are undergoing a similar transition to subscription models, more slowly.) 2. Simplified browsing...Grandparents and small children don't want the full web... Apps. Remember this list is from just one year after the…

Number 3 isn't just in flux, I'd argue it got worse. Companies like Facebook trying to act as definitive platforms while trying to keep their hands clean of being sources or generators means that we have even more fragmented news sources, but significantly more centralized distribution. This means that not only does the quality and veracity of news articles decrease, but the likelihood of someone believing something from a "trusted" platform increases. It's the worst of both worlds.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#66
post #10

It's interesting to read the list and contemplate among other things the ideas that have arguably been solved (or at least partially solved) but in ways that weren't obvious. For example, #1 about RIAA, I'd argue that it was never solved but with streaming stations in particular, it's just not such a pressing issue today. Some certainly haven't happened (e.g. fixing news). The list also seems to assume a lot more rep…

I think the replacement of incumbents is interesting. You have the classic AirBnB from Craigslist. I think that's in their founding story. I also use an app called Reverb. It is basically a sliver of Craigslist or Ebay. I'm not sure what other examples are out there but I bet there is still more meat on that bone. :) Certainly these sites are one-to-one replacements but they are taking out a section of the incumbent…

Catawiki certainly is.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#67
post #46

My take (just the first five): 1. A cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom. Spotify & Apple Music. Pay $10/mo for unlimited access to most music. Took the wind out of music piracy. (TV & film are undergoing a similar transition to subscription models, more slowly.) 2. Simplified browsing...Grandparents and small children don't want the full web... Apps. Remember this list is from just one year after the…

> 3. New news. For this one, I would definitely say Twitter. As an example, my first info about the recent school shooting in Florida was a tweet by a scared student. Anything that happens anywhere in the world will spread on Twitter literally in an instant, and the same goes for non-realtime content published elsewhere.

And yet from a business perspective, Twitter is doing terribly. The news platforms we seem to gravitate to don't end up being profitable.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#68
post #58
post #46

My take (just the first five): 1. A cure for the disease of which the RIAA is a symptom. Spotify & Apple Music. Pay $10/mo for unlimited access to most music. Took the wind out of music piracy. (TV & film are undergoing a similar transition to subscription models, more slowly.) 2. Simplified browsing...Grandparents and small children don't want the full web... Apps. Remember this list is from just one year after the…

> 3. New news. NY Times topped $1 billion in subscription revenue last year. Quite a feat and definitely an indication that money is to be made in digital news. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/08/business/new-york-times-c...

There's a lot of evidence that a large part of the NYTimes revenue surge is a "Trump bump", and that, more broadly, there are way too many media outlets offering free content for the same limited number of eyeballs, and they're burning a lot of VC dollars in the process:

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/theres-a-digital-media-...

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#69
My main problem with this list is that in most of the cases it's basically asking for "faster horses". Most of the items are not problems themselves, but traditional and long existing solutions for problems: news (for the problem of being informed), dating sites (for the problem of meeting romantic partners), auctions (the problem of buying and selling unwanted items), advertising (for the problem in making money when publishing content) etc. The WebOS, really? Sir Tim solved that long ago.

Re: Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund (2008)

#70
post #42

I would love it if someone tackled the auctions market better. Ebay continues to focus more on being a marketplace, and promoting buy it nows. A real auction house should extend the time limit as long as people are putting in bids.

I'm amazed auctions have not taken over live show tickets. Scalpers skim off millions of dollars every year that events/middleman startup could capture themselves if only someone designed a proper live show ticket auction.

TicketSwap is very popular in Amsterdam.
Post reply on HN