Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

wsj.com

61–70 of 271 posts

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#62
post #24

Given so much of the video content (at least high 80s percent wise) on Facebook is simply pirated from YouTube and other creators, it seems more than a little unethical for them to start emblazoning them with ads. But, they'll happily sit behind the DMCA Safe Harbor, slowly taking down videos and reaping the ad revenue in the meanwhile without giving any of it back to creators...

It's hard to imagine a less ethical company in silicon valley than Facebook so it's not surprising

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#63
post #51

I will never understand why people insist on using Facebook. What is the appeal? If you’re worth talking to, I will give you my phone number and we can text. For longer messages, I will send you an email. I can keep track of my contacts inside the Address book of my phone. What need exactly is Facebook filling?

For me Facebook fills the need of a centralized place to communicate with my close friends via Messenger, a place to keep track of niche interests via groups, and a place to get invites to events by friends that I don't see or talk to as often. I also use it to keep track of a few news sources.

I get it that some people don't want to use Facebook, but you really can't understand why other people make a different decision?

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#64
post #27

If I was Facebook, I'd start to think about how to add more value to people's lives. Their monetisation strategy is becoming increasingly annoying and their service is not adding enough value to counter that. People will eventually leave if you irritate them enough (see also comments on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15922022 )

I think Google realized this a long time ago and it's also part of why they failed with Google plus. They just weren't willing to go down into the gutter the way Facebook is and try to suck up people's time to a ridiculous extent. They have remained too concerned, if you will, with providing actual value and Facebook, from day one, has never had that as a concern as their only concern is getting you to use the app as much as humanly possible.

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#66
post #5

Why are they allowed to monetize so much pirated/freebooted content?

It's doomed to fail. YouTube allows creators to profit and build businesses for themselves. Facebook shares none of it's revenue with creators and this is not a sustainable model in the long term.

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#67
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I've yet to have anyone mention something with a "didn't you see that on Facebook?" Any chance this is because you don't know what you've missed, and hence you don't talk to people about them?

Anecdotal, but the only time I've ever hear that phrase in the past 3 years is for my college meme group (one of the few reasons I am still on Facebook). As far as I know, nothing happens on Facebook for anyone under 25. As you get older, life event announcements are about the only thing I can imagine would be useful.

Maybe it's just my friend group, but absolutely everything is scheduled and planned through Facebook events. I basically don't visit, I use Social Fixer to trim down the news feed when I do, but Events is invaluable.

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#68
post #56
post #32

Facebook has become almost completely useless to me yet I waste so much time on it every day. No one posts anything on it except like 3 guys who post 10 times a day that I barely know yet find their extremist political posts mind numbingly amusing. The news on there is trash, I much prefer the WSJ and if I want sensationalist things I'll go to Reddit and my tastes are more niche now so I have some forums I visit occa…

The greatest thing I did was delete Facebook off my phone. Here are the benefits I discovered: - I didn't miss anything. Turns out there wasn't any real quality content on there anyway. - My battery lasts 2x longer. - I seem to be happier. No joke. With all the rage articles and click bait headlines gone, I am far more happier. - I am way more informed now. I visit allsides.com and get the news there. I quickly get u…

- Spend much more time on HackerNews.

Jokes aside, I did the same. Its a healthy move, I also forgot my FB password on my main computer and have not gone through the trouble of using chrome to look it up.

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#69
post #32

Facebook has become almost completely useless to me yet I waste so much time on it every day. No one posts anything on it except like 3 guys who post 10 times a day that I barely know yet find their extremist political posts mind numbingly amusing. The news on there is trash, I much prefer the WSJ and if I want sensationalist things I'll go to Reddit and my tastes are more niche now so I have some forums I visit occa…

[deleted]

Re: Facebook Will Introduce Ads as Videos Start, a Move Long Resisted

#70

Did company resist X? Does company need to generate more revenue? Company will give in to X.

Presumably they didn't do it cause they wanted to build a userbase though. It was always gonna be monetized they just preferred growth to money initially.
Post reply on HN