Live data from Hacker News

Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

blog.google

61–70 of 76 posts

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#61

My biggest problem with Google Drive is its pricing. Why is your 1TB $100/year, when pretty much every major competitor charges $60? $100/yr would buy me 5TB with Microsoft OneDrive. Even Apple, which usually has crazy margins on everything, gives you 2TB for $10/month.

If that extra $40 a year causes them to not shut it down so fast, I'm all for it :)

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#62
post #53
post #28

Maybe one day soon we'll see an official Linux client.

Ok but which Linux? Ubuntu? Fedora? Mint? etc... Which desktop should they integrate with? Gnome? KDE? I suppose they could go the Steam route and only support Ubuntu, but then that would be Ubuntu support, not really Linux support. It would be nice to have at least some support on Linux for sure, but unfortunately deciding to support Linux isn't an answer to a question, it's opening a whole extra big bag full of kno…

Insync is a Google Drive client that has been "providing first class Linux support in any professional, commercial grade application" for years. Also, what do desktop environments have to do with Google Drive clients?

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#63
post #5

Can someone explain what this adds over Google Drive? More importantly, is it taking anything away? The blog post sure didn't provide that necessary info.

If it's backup, it should not work the same way: deletions should not be synced for example.

You can elect not to sync deletions in the new application.

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#64

Can someone explain what this adds over Google Drive? More importantly, is it taking anything away? The blog post sure didn't provide that necessary info.

It doesn't take anything away from the current Google Drive client. It adds more features such as adding more folders to sync, choosing whether the images in those folders get synced to Google Photos, adding USB media support, and deletion options.

It also has a lot of bug fixes over the older client.

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#65
post #18

Because Google Photos does not have an Android TV app, I periodically do a full Google Takeout to pull all my images so that I may rsync newer ones over to my NAS so that they appear in Plex and my wife can then view them on the Google TV. Can you stop reinventing things that already exist, and perhaps fix things that are real customer pain points. Like not being able to view Photos on an Android TV, like not being a…

If Google Photos is the primary ingestion engine for you, you could do this (a suggestion):

1. Go to Drive online. Go to Settings

2. Enable "Create a Google Photos folder"

3. Download the Backup and Sync client, and sync Google Photos to a place on your computer.

4. Periodically have rsync copy new files to your NAS via a scheduler.

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am mystified as to why Google keeps ignoring Linux especially for Drive. Don't a non-trivial number of Google employees run Linux? It also rules out Drive for company wide deployment if any of the people are using Linux, since they will be excluded. That is one thing Dropbox at least gets right.

Linux marketshare is around 1.5%, and I'd speculate those choosing Linux tend to be less willing to trust google/the cloud with their data than average. It's just not worth it when the best-case outcome is indistinguishable from a rounding error,

You are talking about individual deployments where plain market share is reasonable. I'm talking about group deployments where multiple people need to work together. In that case the solution has to work for everyone.

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#67
post #60
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not going to be easy to just put Google Photos on Android TV. Android TV has no concept of accounts or privacy so the only way it could really work right now is to either open up the entire user's photos to anyone currently using the TV or invent some sort of hard to use scheme such as only displaying photos "tagged" a certain way as public/tv which most people probably won't do. Or they could ask for a PIN each…

Can you cast photos from the Photos app in your phone?

Yes. Which makes sense because you are actively sharing them and can end the display whenever you want. No privacy issues.

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#68

This is confusing in so many ways 1. They give no mention of how this handles existing installs of Google Drive or Google Photos Backup. 2. The application has the exact same name for Google Photos and Google Drive. Do I need to download and install both? I tried that, but couldn't move the second to my applications directory without overwriting the first. Looking at the downloads they're the same size, so I'm guessi…

1. If you have Google Drive for PC/Mac installed, it will update it to Backup and Sync. 2. The difference in the two endpoints are the defaults selected during the setup wizard (which you can change from either). The Photos versions is geared more towards Photos users and the Drive users more towards Drive. 3. They are saved in Drive, and are synced to Photos. However if you delete in either Drive or Photos cloud, it…

How does that work given that a google Photos has different pricing for compressed photos?

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. If you have Google Drive for PC/Mac installed, it will update it to Backup and Sync. 2. The difference in the two endpoints are the defaults selected during the setup wizard (which you can change from either). The Photos versions is geared more towards Photos users and the Drive users more towards Drive. 3. They are saved in Drive, and are synced to Photos. However if you delete in either Drive or Photos cloud, it…

How does that work given that a google Photos has different pricing for compressed photos?

It utilizes similar pricing for photos and videos.

You can elect to upload Photos/Videos in High Quality (which does not consume quota).

Re: Introducing Backup and Sync for Google Photos and Google Drive

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same here. iCloud comes very close, but it's horribly unreliable, and there is no way to keep it from delete certain files you might still be working with. I had gigabytes to spare, and it deleted a pretty big file while I had it open in Photoshop, I couldn't figure out why Photoshop wouldn't save it, and it was because iCloud had deleted it while I was using it. Now, it's been stuck at uploading 200 files/200 for ab…

How did that even happen? Had you not saved the file recently? iCloud chooses what to delete based on size and last access. If you were working on the file and had saved it at least once, it would be impossible for it to delete it.

Opening the file at all should update the 'last accessed' time, no save required.
Post reply on HN