Live data from Hacker News

Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

ironedcurtains.com

61–70 of 132 posts

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#61
“Everyone who thinks the EPA is not necessary and the regulations on power plants are there to stifle growth and profit should read every comment here… ”— Ilya K.

Didn't this catastrophe happen in a communist country with the government in complete control of all aspects? The presence of a government agency regulating the activity is not like some magic amulet that will prevent bad things from occurring.

The EPA has caused its own share of disasters, such as the MBTE fiasco.

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#63

The interviews are interesting. I was a kid those days, and my mother keeps telling me that diary products were suddenly put on a sale (before the news release). I live in Eastern-Europe, in the former Warsaw Pact bloc. My father worked in a research institute, so managed to get a hold of the information before the official announcements. He told her not to buy any diary or vegetable for a while. ---- What troubles m…

Ya we better destroy all life on earth so you can keep your lifestyle.

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you list scarcity of uranium as an issue for nuclear, then advocate for hydro without mentioning the same? There are only so many suitable locations for hydro, and the further down the list we go the worse the incremental environmental impact.

Tidal is hydro and has barely been tapped.

My intent was not to advocate for nuclear, just to push back at a one sided argument.

You can make a compelling case for anything if you leave out inconvenient details.

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you list scarcity of uranium as an issue for nuclear, then advocate for hydro without mentioning the same? There are only so many suitable locations for hydro, and the further down the list we go the worse the incremental environmental impact.

Tidal is hydro and has barely been tapped.

[deleted]

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#66
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I see on HN is a stream of technological idealism that tends to ignore the practical difficulties. Blaming protestors for lack of progress is very easy as it allows you to neatly ignore those issues. There are many economic and engineering reasons why nuclear is so hard to get right.

France, a rich, functional, liberal, western democracy, is more or less uncontroversially nuclear powered to a very high degree. There are no more practical difficulties than any other large, important project. The only problem is politics.

That's like saying that building a road is no more difficult than launching a rocket into orbit.

It turns out that nuclear physics is really quite hard. That is not a reason to not do something. But we shouldn't take these issues so lightly.

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#67
post #6

Any chance there's a Russian version of this somewhere?

Editor here. These were originally written in English, so we have plans to translate to Russian, which might take a while since we only have one fully-qualified translator. Help is welcome! Shoot me an email (included in my profile).

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#68

The interviews are interesting. I was a kid those days, and my mother keeps telling me that diary products were suddenly put on a sale (before the news release). I live in Eastern-Europe, in the former Warsaw Pact bloc. My father worked in a research institute, so managed to get a hold of the information before the official announcements. He told her not to buy any diary or vegetable for a while. ---- What troubles m…

It's "dairy", not "diary".

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#69
Great documentary about Chernobyl can be watched here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezohqY-vg4s&feature=player_e...

It touches on all aspects of the accident and cleanup. There are a lot of good interviews and actual footage from the event. The most amazing/sad part to me were the men who did the clean up in 30 second - 1 minute shifts.

Re: Eye-witness stories from Chernobyl

#70
Some people who post comments didn't read the article - thousands of people dying of cancer, children loosing hair, etc. It wasn't just 36 people, it's couple million tragedies, as their families were affected, themselves, children because of the lies of the communists
Post reply on HN