Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

whatmoji.com

61–70 of 81 posts

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#61
post #32

I feel like http://emojipedia.org/ is a better website with more information. I've been regularly using it since Emoji have become a thing. It gives more context about the meaning of symbols, is easier to search the other way, and also shows how the image appears on various different platforms.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#62

It still doesn't really tell you what it means, just the name/annotation.

They can mean different things based on what set of renderings you're using for the same emoji... good writeup here https://eev.ee/blog/2016/04/12/apple-did-not-invent-emoji/

That essay has a good grasp of why we want unicode, but completely missed the point of why we want emoticons. If I send an image to someone, I don't want it to be rendered in an unpredictable way based on their unknown system and font choices. I need to know that they see what I intended to send.

Everyone would be happier if they were embedded images; that's what we all want. They're shoehorned into unicode instead because that makes it technically easier to send them in text messages, not because they're textual objects.

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#63
post #45
post #32

I feel like http://emojipedia.org/ is a better website with more information. I've been regularly using it since Emoji have become a thing. It gives more context about the meaning of symbols, is easier to search the other way, and also shows how the image appears on various different platforms.

Emojipedia doesn't say anything about alternative meanings for the peach or eggplant emojis. I need something for more cultural meanings, too.

http://emojipedia.org/peach/

> Also Known as Butt Emoji

http://emojipedia.org/aubergine/

> Also Known as Phallic Emoji

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They can mean different things based on what set of renderings you're using for the same emoji... good writeup here https://eev.ee/blog/2016/04/12/apple-did-not-invent-emoji/

That essay has a good grasp of why we want unicode, but completely missed the point of why we want emoticons. If I send an image to someone, I don't want it to be rendered in an unpredictable way based on their unknown system and font choices. I need to know that they see what I intended to send. Everyone would be happier if they were embedded images; that's what we all want. They're shoehorned into unicode instead b…

Technically, you don't know your text will render the same on someone else's device. For all you know, they could have their system font set to Wingdings.

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That essay has a good grasp of why we want unicode, but completely missed the point of why we want emoticons. If I send an image to someone, I don't want it to be rendered in an unpredictable way based on their unknown system and font choices. I need to know that they see what I intended to send. Everyone would be happier if they were embedded images; that's what we all want. They're shoehorned into unicode instead b…

Technically, you don't know your text will render the same on someone else's device. For all you know, they could have their system font set to Wingdings.

I don't care about that (see my comment, "They're shoehorned into unicode instead because that makes it technically easier to send them in text messages, not because they're textual objects"). Text is grouped into several equivalence classes. I only need them to recognize any L that I send as an L.

If I send a facial expression, I need to know what I'm sending. Those do not have defined equivalence classes.

Re: Show HN: I couldn't figure out what an Emoji meant, so I made WhatMoji.com

#70
I believe emoji is designed to be expressive, if we need to look it up in a emoji dictionary ,then emoji goes wrong. The fact is that everybody wants to add their favourite emoji, but more emoji added more confusion it will be make. Just imagine we lookup an emoji before we send to others, and the receiver has to look it up in a dictionary to know what the sender want to express. Why not just using the normal words we already know very well
Post reply on HN