Live data from Hacker News

Why can't China make a good ballpoint pen?

marketplace.org

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: Why can't China make a good ballpoint pen?

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ehhh, I don't buy it's simple a wage/motivation issue You know cheap immigrant labor in the US also makes squat and they don't do generally do a shabby job. The issue is that no one is held to a high standard here. In the US if you do a sloppy job you'll get fired and they'll find someone who can do it better for the same horrible wage. Here "average" work is expected an no one really seems to mind (as long as "it ge…

Immigrant labor in the states isn't paid 10 Kuai an hour, and the American government isn't so worried about a peasant uprising that they would want to keep all the low skilled labor particularly busy. To the CCP, however, the construction industry is just a big jobs program for farmers who can't find enough work in the country side, hence the heavy use of concrete (easy to work with) and overbuilt buildings that fee…

Well the first part is very true and the fact that the gov't doesn't really care about quality (just as long as people are working) probably fuels the culture of mediocrity, but this really doesn't apply to the private sector where in a different cultural climate the employers would always demand excellence. I mean at the end of the day it's sorta understandable b/c you just have to not be a ton worse than your competitors - and think of the savings!

I'm sure it's very different from Singapore/Taiwan/HK (though judging by the lack of attention to detail by immigrants in San Francisco I'll wait to see for myself), but this is a country of peasants/farmers run by peasants and farmers. It's going to take a very very long time for the culture to change - I'm talking several generations - b/c it's the culture of the "weakest-link". I guess their only blessing is that they have these other places to learn from.

Re: Why can't China make a good ballpoint pen?

#62
What's the article did not talk about is Gree, the air conditioner company, actually had a robotics and precision machinery division since 2012 and they have just unveiled its first products including several industrial robots, a 3 axis CNC machine and a 5 axis CNC machine during a trade show in August of 2015.

She probably saw this as marketing opportunity to upset existing player in the field. Come to think of it, the ability to make a cheap precision ballpoint could also to translated to ball bearings, and that has a market orders of magnitudes bigger than ballpoint pens.

Post reply on HN