Live data from Hacker News

Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

theguardian.com

61–70 of 161 posts

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#61
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, there are all sorts of forms about material representations and liabilities for false statements. It seems like a well-run program, our contacts with the ATO were very sharp and knew which questions to ask. You could tell they've ferreted out fraudulent applications before.

Sounds like something most companies won't touch with a nine foot pole.

If you're honest, it's a great source of money. Our company was doing actual research to the tune of $50M spent in Australia (which was all VC money) so we got back something like $20M in non-dilutive additional financing. That $20M was "free" to us (but we lost out on the ability to write off $50M of losses against our future profits). It encouraged us to spend much more on research which mostly came in the form of salaries for Austrian employees. As long as you're not in the habit of lying to tax authorities, I don't know why every startup wouldn't take advantage.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#62
post #12

From the article: > Guardian Australia understands the raids are not related to the claims that Wright may have been involved in the creation of bitcoin, but are related to an Australian Tax Office investigation. So the story is that the Australian Tax Office just happened to be running an investigation looking into some facet of Craig Wright's finances. An investigation that apparently revealed some sort of abnormal…

To me it seems that leaks are partially caused by the tax investigation, not the other way around.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#63
post #31

http://www.businessinsider.com.au/the-australian-who-may-hav... "Under the scheme, a company which turns over less than $20 million is eligible to apply for a cash rebate of 45 cents for every dollar spent on research and development activity. According to a press release in May, 2015, DeMorgan Ltd succeeded in its application for the rebate. That means DeMorgan were able to prove to AusIndustry that it had spent $12…

I'm a consultant in the R&D Tax space. The press release relates to an advanced finding, which is an advanced approval of R&D activities. It does not however guarantee approval for the amount of expenditure they would be claiming. A tax refund of that size would naturally attract the attention of the Australian Tax Office(ATO). The press release is also dated before they could submit their tax return to obtain a 14/15 refund. A key problem with the press release is that there is now a $100million cap on how much expenditure they can claim in a financial year, so theoretically their maximum benefit would be $45million.

$120million in software R&D is a very large spend in Australia for one year, Google Australia for example claims about $40-$50million in R&D spend each year. Atlassian and some of the larger banks would claim a similar amount. I have not heard much about DeMorgan before, however if it all checks out they would be one of the most significant powers in the Australian tech space.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#64
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But if he's Satoshi, he can take the moral high ground and wage a media campaign to shame the ATO into dropping the case and maybe finally correctly treating Bitcoin as money. How does this help? If they treat it that way, wouldn't Wright have a huge income tax debt?

> wouldn't Wright have a huge income tax debt? Yes, but presumably he can pay it out of his Bitcoin fortune. He has to deal with that at some point anyway, and by going public now, he gains additional leverage on his VAT or tax credit or whatever the ATO has decided to get him for this time.

Bitcoin is still volatile.

Typically tax on volatile income is paid when you "cash out" to a more stable currency.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#65
post #12

From the article: > Guardian Australia understands the raids are not related to the claims that Wright may have been involved in the creation of bitcoin, but are related to an Australian Tax Office investigation. So the story is that the Australian Tax Office just happened to be running an investigation looking into some facet of Craig Wright's finances. An investigation that apparently revealed some sort of abnormal…

Yeah, because virtual currency can't possibly have anything to do with tax evasion.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#66
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a strong incentive for SN to stay anonymous now: extortion, GBH threats, kidnapping, tax evasion, etc. This could be some guy feigning humblebragging to fool prospective customers, or the vaguest individual Wired decided to hoist the label onto because it garners eyeballs in a Daily Mail way that's hard to repute. The raid is explained because many governments want evidence for tax evasion and evading the co…

Many governments are interested in finding Satoshi. They need a scapegoat to pin this bitcoin thing on. They still believe finding him/her might be effective method of getting rid of bitcoin. It's like trump wanting to go ask bill gates about locking up the internet.

Proof for these ludicrous statements please.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#67
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a strong incentive for SN to stay anonymous now: extortion, GBH threats, kidnapping, tax evasion, etc. This could be some guy feigning humblebragging to fool prospective customers, or the vaguest individual Wired decided to hoist the label onto because it garners eyeballs in a Daily Mail way that's hard to repute. The raid is explained because many governments want evidence for tax evasion and evading the co…

Many governments are interested in finding Satoshi. They need a scapegoat to pin this bitcoin thing on. They still believe finding him/her might be effective method of getting rid of bitcoin. It's like trump wanting to go ask bill gates about locking up the internet.

Proof for these ludicrous statements please.

Re: Reported Bitcoin 'founder' Craig Wright's home raided by Australian police

#70
Here is an Amazon comment left by Wright. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CVvsxDOVAAANOD-.png:large

"Silicone" Valley? "Assumed to the centre of everything"?

Color me skeptical that this guy is Satoshi.

(source: https://twitter.com/kashhill/status/674393417019883520 )

Post reply on HN