Live data from Hacker News

Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

reuters.com

581–590 of 1001 posts

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#582

How does this differ from Russia invading Ukraine? We have to wake up to the world where USA no longer cares about ideals like liberal democracy or allies, but is a warmongering corporatist autocracy.

Russia's goal is to destroy Ukraine as nation and a country, because there's no "Ukrainians", there's no "Ukrainian language", and every country that speaks Russian should be controlled by Russian tsar. That's why they don't care and demolish ("liberate") Ukraine, town after town.

Do US do/want the same for Venezuela?

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#583
To steel-man and provide a more charitable interpretation of last night:

1. Maduro stole an election. He is not legitimately in power. Many other people in power, like the military and other political factions, opposed this and wants him removed.

2. These people quietly oust Maduro in the middle of the night.

3. With the tacit approval of these folks, the US arrests Maduro for previously indicted crimes.

4. The US bombs some bases, providing plausible deniability to Venezuelan military. This was coordinated and the Venezuelans abandoned these sites ahead of time.

5. There is still stability because most of the people in charge are still there. Only the illegitimate president is gone. Venezuela can have a real election now.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#584

As a Latino and friend of several people that scaped from Maduro's regime I can easily say that people in South America are happy as ever. Also, some people seems to miss the fact that South America military power is very weak, and we, culturally, are way less proned to fight and die than people in middle east. Yeah, we know this is all about oil, and I'm interested to know what kind of democracy will emerge. But the…

> As a Latino and friend of several people that scaped from Maduro's regime I can easily say that people in South America are happy as ever.

No, we aren't. You don't speak for the majority of us.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#586

I will spare saying the obvious illegality of such actions and how serious this is. I will just say something else: I grew up as a kid between the 80s and 90s, when the world felt like it was going towards a brighter age of peace and respect. Berlin wall falling, China opening, Apartheid ending in South Africa, even Palestine and Israel were moving towards a more peaceful future. But since then the world has just pro…

> a brighter age of peace and respect

The first thing to learn from a well-examined life and study of history is that we must always be vigilant and active to protect progress and human betterment.

The second thing to learn from recent history is that transnational petroleum interests will not quietly and meekly surrender their control, influence and interests.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#587

It's funny how many people already see this as a book that is opened and closed on the same day. That's not how these things work. This is like the first stone of an avalanche. It could stop here, or it could roll on for quite a while. It will take months or even years to know whether or not the outcome here was desirable or not and what the final tally is. Remember the 'Arab spring' and what came after.

Panama was an opened and closed book in practically less than a week.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#588

I almost feel bad for the people who instigated the War on Terror. They did not know how badly it would go - and they worked really hard and tirelessly to build and sell their illegitimate case to the American public. This administration is making the same mistakes - but in living memory of the first, with a less noble prize, and with complete derision of Congress and Americans' intelligence.

I don't want to defend Trump - starting a war is about the most serious thing a country can do, and doing it unilaterally is terrible. Trump should be condemned for this.

But most of those doing the condemning were also supportive of Pres. Obama (or at least refused to condemn his actions) back in 2011 when he attacked Libya, and in 2013 and 2014 when he attacked Syria -- all of this happening after we should have learned from what we were doing in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Those people who didn't protest against Pres. Obama's illegal actions have lost moral high ground to protest against Trump.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#589

To steel-man and provide a more charitable interpretation of last night: 1. Maduro stole an election. He is not legitimately in power. Many other people in power, like the military and other political factions, opposed this and wants him removed. 2. These people quietly oust Maduro in the middle of the night. 3. With the tacit approval of these folks, the US arrests Maduro for previously indicted crimes. 4. The US bo…

> Venezuela can have a real election now

Assuming the US wants and will allow that. Which isn’t at all clear, given the desire to get a hold of Venezuelan oil.

Re: Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes

#590
post #411

I think people are overindexed on the US's failures to turn Islamic theocracies into democracies. The people in Venezuela want democracy. It's a fundamentally different situation.

And the US want oil and other resources.

So Venezuela has to vote correctly otherwise it will get "freed" again

Post reply on HN