Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

nytimes.com

581–590 of 761 posts

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#581

After their recent change in tune to retain data for longer and to train on our data, I deleted my account. Try to do that. There is no easy way to delete your account. You need to reach out to their support via email. Incredibly obnoxious dark pattern. I hate OpenAI, but everything with Anthropic also smells fishy. We need more and better players. I hope that XAi will give them all some good competition, but I have…

X doesn't smell fishy to you??

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#583
post #315

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I think a free society needs to let people break the rules if they are willing to pay the cost so you don't think super rich people should be bound by laws at all? Unless you made the cost proportional to (maybe expontial to) somebody's wealth, you would be creating a completely lawless class who would wreak havoc on society.

Hate to break it to you, but that's currently the world we live in. And yes, it sucks.

The “cost” should not be associated with money

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#584

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It was faster to just put unlicensed taxis on the streets and use investor money to pay fines and lobby for favorable legislation And thank god they did. There was no perfectly legal channel to fix the taxi cartel. Now you don't even have to use Uber in many of these places because taxis had to compete - they otherwise never would have stopped pulling the "credit card reader is broken" scam, taking long routes on p…

i dont know that its such a great thing in the end. Uber/Lyft is 50-100% more expensive now than taxis were before. Theyre entrenched in different ways.

So are most things from 20 years ago. Inflation is acting as the majority of those increases I’d wager.

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#585
post #228

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Buying used copies of books, scanning them, and training on it is fine. But nobody was ever going to that, not when there are billions in VC dollars at stake for whoever moves fastest. Everybody will simply risk the fine, which tends to not be anywhere close to enough to have a deterrent effect in the future. That is like saying Uber would have not had any problems if they just entered into a licensing contract wit…

> It was faster to just put unlicensed taxis on the streets and use investor money to pay fines and lobby for favorable legislation And thank god they did. There was no perfectly legal channel to fix the taxi cartel. Now you don't even have to use Uber in many of these places because taxis had to compete - they otherwise never would have stopped pulling the "credit card reader is broken" scam, taking long routes on p…

What about the problem of sexual assault by drivers?

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/06/business/uber-sexual-assa...

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#586

After their recent change in tune to retain data for longer and to train on our data, I deleted my account. Try to do that. There is no easy way to delete your account. You need to reach out to their support via email. Incredibly obnoxious dark pattern. I hate OpenAI, but everything with Anthropic also smells fishy. We need more and better players. I hope that XAi will give them all some good competition, but I have…

Their logo is a butt hole.

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#587
post #585

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It was faster to just put unlicensed taxis on the streets and use investor money to pay fines and lobby for favorable legislation And thank god they did. There was no perfectly legal channel to fix the taxi cartel. Now you don't even have to use Uber in many of these places because taxis had to compete - they otherwise never would have stopped pulling the "credit card reader is broken" scam, taking long routes on p…

What about the problem of sexual assault by drivers? https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/06/business/uber-sexual-assa...

what about it?

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#588

After the book publishers burned Google Book's Library of Alexandria, they are now making it impossible to train a LLM unless you engage in the medieval process of manually buying paper-copies of work just to scan & destroy them...

If they wanted a copyright free world maybe they should publish all their models as copyright free as well. But they are not doing it are they?

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#589

After their recent change in tune to retain data for longer and to train on our data, I deleted my account. Try to do that. There is no easy way to delete your account. You need to reach out to their support via email. Incredibly obnoxious dark pattern. I hate OpenAI, but everything with Anthropic also smells fishy. We need more and better players. I hope that XAi will give them all some good competition, but I have…

I think it's fair to call out a dark pattern for account deletion (which, for better or worse, is common practice) - but the data training and data retention thing can both be disabled...I was much more surprised that they DIDN'T train on data as long as they did, when every other LLM provider was sucking in as much data as they could (OpenAI, Google, Meta, and xAI - although Meta gets a pass for providing the open-weight models in my head).

Anthropic has made AI safety a central pillar of their ethos and have shared a lot of information about what they're doing to responsibly train models...personally I found a lot of corporate-speak on this topic from OpenAI, but very little information.

Re: Anthropic agrees to pay $1.5B to settle lawsuit with book authors

#590

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m an author, can I get in on this?

I had the same question. It looks like you'll be able to search this site if the settlement is approved: > https://www.anthropiccopyrightsettlement.com/ If your work is there, you qualify for a slice of the settlement. If not, you're outta luck.

I didn't see a way to search for my book there, but there definitely is an author intake form.

This site references Meta, but the training corpus probably has some overlap? Maybe?

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2025/03/searc...

Post reply on HN