Live data from Hacker News

6 weeks of Claude Code

blog.puzzmo.com

571–580 of 603 posts

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#571

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlikely. Microsoft had layoffs everywhere except India. There they keep hiring more. As song as the can keep upskilling themselves while still being much cheaper than US workers they won't fear unemployment. Just yesterday I saw on X a video of a Miami hotel where the check-in procedure was via a video call to a receptionist in India.

Six months from now, that singular worker if they are still employed, will manage a high number of receptionist avatars. And then they themselves will be replaced. It will still lead to a massive collapse in the labor market and with all of that excess labor, existing jobs while being overworked will still see flat to decreasing wages.

You overestimate how chatbots can replace people.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#572

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> 2. Start with a good spec. Spend enough time on the spec. You can get AI to write most of the spec for you, if you provide a good outline. Curious how you outline the spec, concretely. A sister markdown document? How detailed is it? etc. > 3. Make sure you have tests from the beginning. This is the most important part. Tests (along with good specs) are how an AI agent can recurse into a good solution. TDD is back.…

I wrote a tool for this, which allows you to co-create and maintain a context repository with your LLMs https://github.com/jerpint/context-llemur CLI for the humans, MCP for the LLMS. Whatever is in the context repository should be used by the LLM for its next steps and you are both responsible for maintaining it as tasks start getting done and the project evolves I’ve been having good success with it so far

I have a similar flow to this, but using files which are part of the repository. For you tool; What made you choose to version it with git but also write context is not code? Wouldn't you end up with multiple versions of say your backlog, and to what benefit?

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#573
post #456

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By the time it works flawlessly, it won't be your career anymore, it'll be the product manager's. They will describe what they want and the AI will produce it. You won't be told to "use Claude all the time". I personally hate coding, but it's a means to an end, and I care about the end. I'm also paranoid about code I don't understand, so I only rarely use AI and even then it's either for things I understand 100% or t…

This is the core of the issue. You hate coding, and I love it. I chose to be a software engineer not because I like using software, but because I like writing software. If we get to a point where the engineers are replaced by machines, I would hope that the project managers were replaced years before that, as a final act of revenge

I don't like X, therefore X isn't true.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#574
post #513

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It'll be interesting to see if in a decade when a whole cohort of juniors didn't get trained whether LLMs will be able to do the whole job. I'm guessing a lot of companies are willing to bet on yes.

The issue is there's a kind of prisoner's dilemma going on - probably some people can see that there's a serious risk of still needing software engineers in 10 years' time and there not being enough because nobody is training juniors in 2025. However, noticing this doesn't help because if you invest in training juniors in 2025 but nobody else does, someone else can just recruit them in 2030 and benefit from your inve…

Yes exactly if workers can just up and leave and treat the job transactionally, that creates a race to the bottom. Workers have to train themselves then.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#575
post #349

Earlier quoted context omitted.

IT education and computer science (at least part of it) will need a stronger focus on software engineering and software architecture skills to teach developers how to be in control of an AI dev tool.

The fastest way is via struggle. Learn to do it yourself first. Understand WHY it does not work. What's good code? What's bad code? What are conventions? There are no shortcuts - you are not an accountant just because you have a calculator.

With that mindset you don't have to go to school, you could learn everything through struggle... Ideally it's a bit of both, you need theory and experience to succeed.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#576

The real power of Claude Code comes when you realise it can do far more than just write code. It can, in fact, control your entire computer. If there's a CLI tool, Claude can run it. If there's not a CLI tool... ask Claude anyway, you might be surprised. E.g. I've used Claude to crop and resize images, rip MP3s from YouTube videos, trim silence from audio files, the list goes on. It saves me incredible amounts of tim…

It's the automators dream come true. Anything can be automated, anything scripted, anything documented. Even if we're gonna use other (possibly local) models in the future, this will be my interface of choice. It's so powerful.

Here's the hope that the demand for software continues to increase as developer productivity rises, and that increases in developer productivity are partially captured in higher salaries.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#577

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah. The only, and I mean only non-social/networking advantages to universities stem from forced learning/reasoning about complex theoretical concepts that form the requisite base knowledge to learn the practical requirements of your field while on the job. Trade schools and certificate programs are designed to churn out people with journeyman-level skills in some field. They repeatedly drill you on the practical da…

It's not a particularly moral way to think, but if you're currently mid level or senior, the junior dev pipeline being cut off will be beneficial to you personally in a few years' time. Potentially very beneficial, if it turns out software engineers are still needed but nobody has been training them for half a decade

It’s clear that it harms those that get to keep their jobs less to some extent (though when you’ve got a glut of talent and few jobs, the only winners are employers because salaries tank eventually.) But frankly, the pervasiveness of that intense greed and self-absorption used to be anathema to the American software industry. Now it looks a lot more like a bunch of private equity bros than a bunch of people who stood to make good money selling creative solutions to the world’s problems. Even worse, the developers that built this business still think they’re part of the in-club, and too special and talented to get tossed out like a bag of moldy peaches. They’re wrong, and it’s sad to watch.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#578
post #349

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I'm hearing from Senior devs all over thought, that Junior developers are just garbage at it. They product slow, insecure, or just outright awful code with it, and then they PR the code they don't even understand. If this is the case then we better have full AI generated code within the next 10 years since those "juniors" will remain atrophied juniors forever and the old timers will be checking in with the big cloc…

IT education and computer science (at least part of it) will need a stronger focus on software engineering and software architecture skills to teach developers how to be in control of an AI dev tool.

In Germany, software engineer is a trade you go to trade school for three years while working in a company in parallel. I don't think that IT education and computer science in universities should have a stronger focus on SE as universities are basically a trade school for being a researcher.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#579
post #349

Earlier quoted context omitted.

IT education and computer science (at least part of it) will need a stronger focus on software engineering and software architecture skills to teach developers how to be in control of an AI dev tool.

In Germany, software engineer is a trade you go to trade school for three years while working in a company in parallel. I don't think that IT education and computer science in universities should have a stronger focus on SE as universities are basically a trade school for being a researcher.

While that path exists, the vast majority of developers don't go through that path.

Re: 6 weeks of Claude Code

#580
post #202

I have about two weeks of using Claude Code and to be honest, as a vibe coding skeptic, I was amazed. It has a learning curve. You need to learn how to give it proper context, how to chunk up the work, etc. And you need to know how to program, obviously. Asking it to do something you don't know how to do, that's just asking for a disaster. I have more than 25 years of experience, so I'm confident with anything Claude…

Feels like the most valuable skill to have as a programmer in times of Claude Code is that of carefully reading spec documentation and having an acute sense of critical thinking when reviewing code.

so... software engineering?
Post reply on HN