Live data from Hacker News

Voltswagen of America

media.vw.com

571–580 of 632 posts

Re: Voltswagen of America

#571

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My dad used to joke that if you wanted sneakers that were not made by child labor, your best bet was whichever manufacturer last got into trouble for it because of all the extra scrutiny. That this level of fatalism about immoral acts exists is a failure of society as a whole. I suspect that all of those who got rich either knowingly or being willfully ignorant about emissions cheating walked away completely unpunish…

Instead of posting uninformed speculation, you can just Google it… > In 2017, the U.S.-based VW executive Oliver Schmidt, who oversaw emissions issues, was sentenced to seven years in prison and fined $400,000, the maximum possible under a plea deal the German national made with prosecutors after admitting to charges of conspiring to mislead U.S regulators and violate clean-air laws. The US has charged nine people, a…

Countries need to ties fees/fines to income level and assets.

It kills me when I read about these paltry fines most wealthy men probably laugh at.

A poor man get a $600 traffic ticket, it could affect rent.

A rich man get the same ticket, and it’s dinner conversation.

Re: Voltswagen of America

#572

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A close associate is an engine designer at a VW group company. VW is not some bottoms up startup. It has a clear micromanaged road map for virtually everything. Data is gathered, sheds are biked ad nausuem. this person was jailed because they were the last one holding the hot potatoe. There is no way (according to said associate) that upper management were not aware of what was going on. as any decision like that has…

> re-map the ECU Sorry, what does this mean in layman's terms?

I can only recommend watching this 2015 talk at German Chaos Communication Congress about the technical details of the scandal. It's in English and really worth watching if you're technically interested. They reverse engineered the ECU configurations and showed how the manipulation works.

https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scand...

Re: Voltswagen of America

#573

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My dad used to joke that if you wanted sneakers that were not made by child labor, your best bet was whichever manufacturer last got into trouble for it because of all the extra scrutiny. That this level of fatalism about immoral acts exists is a failure of society as a whole. I suspect that all of those who got rich either knowingly or being willfully ignorant about emissions cheating walked away completely unpunish…

we decouple too much, every company is trying to survive the market and will always cut corners even though in the end no one ever asked for children to make shoes.. it was just global fear, frustration and risk that made everybody put pressure in the wrong direction.

How do you mean "survive the market"? Survive as in answer to shareholders with higher profits or succumb to consumer demand for cheaper shoes?

In reality it's the former and the latter is stoked through other means.

Re: Voltswagen of America

#574
post #403

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Never heard of this before, I looked it up, but I still don't get it -- you're not getting more power, you're not getting better fuel efficiency, you're not getting a smoother ride, what's the point - you're literally burning money for no reason?

It's a popular way of making a political statement: Own the libs!

cut off your nose to spite your face

Re: Voltswagen of America

#575
post #568

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He was in "Offener Vollzug" (~open prison). That means he sleeps in a normal prison cell (that usually looks like [1], so not all that bad) in a regular prison, gets breakfeast, leaves prison to go to work, then goes straight back to prison to participate in the prison's evening activities (sport, recreational, educational, etc). He might get vacation (from staying in prison), and can visit his family on weekends. It…

What are the 84% that aren't in open prison? Poor people who don't have a corporate apparatus to hide their crimes behind? Volkswagen emissions killed people with smog. VW are homicidal.

Corruption is a real problem in Germany and auto makers have a lot of influence on politicians, so the corporate and the political apparatus are interested in hiding these crimes, because a large part of our economy depends on them.

Re: Voltswagen of America

#576

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More recently, he has been released on parole after roughly half his term served.[1] Interestingly, the article says: In Germany, inmates can be released after serving two thirds of their term. Parole after only half of the time is rare, but can be granted to first time offenders who demonstrated good behavior and are deemed unlikely to commit crimes in the future. I don't doubt he exhibited good behavior. I'm not su…

A close associate is an engine designer at a VW group company. VW is not some bottoms up startup. It has a clear micromanaged road map for virtually everything. Data is gathered, sheds are biked ad nausuem. this person was jailed because they were the last one holding the hot potatoe. There is no way (according to said associate) that upper management were not aware of what was going on. as any decision like that has…

> sheds are biked ad nausuem

What does this mean?

Re: Voltswagen of America

#577

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A close associate is an engine designer at a VW group company. VW is not some bottoms up startup. It has a clear micromanaged road map for virtually everything. Data is gathered, sheds are biked ad nausuem. this person was jailed because they were the last one holding the hot potatoe. There is no way (according to said associate) that upper management were not aware of what was going on. as any decision like that has…

> sheds are biked ad nausuem What does this mean?

It's from an old parable, also called Parkinson's Law of Triviality. Basically, simple things get discussed more because everyone can understand them. It goes something like this:

"If a committee designs a bikeshed, they will spend five minutes discussing the structural requirements, half an hour on the size, and the rest of the available time arguing about what color to paint the shed."

Re: Voltswagen of America

#579
post #577

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> sheds are biked ad nausuem What does this mean?

It's from an old parable, also called Parkinson's Law of Triviality . Basically, simple things get discussed more because everyone can understand them. It goes something like this: "If a committee designs a bikeshed, they will spend five minutes discussing the structural requirements, half an hour on the size, and the rest of the available time arguing about what color to paint the shed."

Oh ok. I wonder why he didn't just say "bikeshedding."

Re: Voltswagen of America

#580

Earlier quoted context omitted.

can I prosecute ex parte the rest of the taxpayers and citizens and asthmatics the administrators supposed to have been in charge of ensuring compliance with emissions standards for failing so incredibly to do their jobs? or is there no responsibility held by whoever we place in office responsible for seeing our futures aren't squandered? how is it possible to ignore that obligation and duty when we've only just star…

I’m not sure if the downvotes here are because of your Trump allusions or not, but you do raise a pretty important point. Where was the oversight? How was it that an open secret of this magnitude didn’t incur the wrath of environmental agencies in the countries affected? Is it possible that no-one outside of the industry knew about this and that everyone in the industry, even in competing firms, just kept this secret…

I agree, the people enforcing these laws are just as negligent. Why did the let the manufactures anywhere near the testing process.

I would like to think that now, after the scandal, they are selecting and testing cars that have recently been sold. The cars that are actually being driven around.

Post reply on HN