Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

news.ycombinator.com

551–560 of 911 posts

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#551
post #271

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We also don't know what the effects of covid are in 10 years.

This argument, while technically true, is relatively dismissive of all that we have learned about the virus. Of primary importance, COVID-19 appears to be easily and completely cleared by the human immune system and does not appear to become latent by settling in immune privileged areas or by integrating itself into the human genome or body in any other way (like Epstein-Barr, Herpesvirus, HIV, etc.) Outside of the m…

You're correct in principle, but when weighing the "unknown long term risks" of a vaccine versus the "unknown long term risks" of COVID itself it really needs to be an apple to apples comparison.

We know both the virus and the vaccine will be out of your system within a short period of time. So any long term effects would have to be derived from what happens while they're in your system. The vaccine generates a few proteins, which your immune system learns to fight off in short order. The virus generates similar proteins, but continues to replicate many times over, attacking your cells and triggering a much more severe immune response as it goes.

So while there are unknown long-term risks for both, I think it is pretty safe to say the number of vectors for long term consequences are much more numerous with the virus.

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#552

I'm surprised to see such a high percentage of "NO" responses. I'm genuinely curious to understand why

I elected "NO" because I have already have had COVID-19 and verified antibodies, and an mRNA vaccine is unlikely to provide any additional level of protection. I believe this should have been a separate option.

How were you able to verify that you have developed anti-bodies?

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#553
post #507

Apart from handling the pandemic in the worst way possible, my country (Sweden) also had the misfortune of being one of the few countries mass-vaccinating against swine flu. This was completely unnecessary and resulted in hundreds of people getting narcolepsy. Even though this was an isolated case of a bad vaccine (Pandemrix) it affected the public opinion a lot, so I'm worried that people will be afraid to take the…

You might not know, but that’s been discredited since. The vaccine didn’t cause narcolepsy. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/concerns-history.... and https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/history/narcoleps...

Interesting. Didn't know at all. It seems like "common knowledge" here in Sweden.

The CDC report isn't mentioned here by the way but should be (in case someone reading this is versed in Wikipedia editing): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandemrix#Adverse_outcomes

This is great news anyway and definitely something I will tell people worried about the vaccine so thanks!

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#554
It's my civic duty to take it as soon as it's offered to me, even if there's some minuscule chance that there will be an averse side effect.

That said, I'll likely be towards the end of the line given my health and occupation.

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#555

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was in Germany in October and with the individual the day they took the second shot. France is a professional contact who mentioned it on the phone, as is China. Same thing happened with tests a few months ago in Palo Alto. Billionaires with boxes of them at their homes while public stocks ran low.

Okay so first of all I'm almost certain no approved vaccine existed in October, the first one started rollout this week, can you back this up with a source? Maybe you knew someone participating in a study but that's not queue skipping. Don't get me wrong I hate billionaires but this just seems like it can't factually be correct.

It doesn't need to be approved to be used, and the results of the trial were likely known for a bit now.

It's easily conceivable that billionaires have been pushing to be 'in the loop' on the meds from the start, and will have gained access long ago to whatever was used in the most promising trials. They can take it as soon as the insider doctors flag that it's ok, likely many weeks before any public announcement, and certainly before any governmental validation.

The value of said vaccines are considerable, there's massive money involved, I wonder if the R&D institutions themselves may have been able to find a loophole to allow for it.

With the sheer number of doctors and patients involved in the trial, and vials worth possibly $100-500K on the black market ... it's bound to get out.

And frankly, who cares? A couple thousand early vaccines is basically meaningless from a public health standpoint. It might even be moral to have publicly auctioned off the first mini batch and put the money into production. It's rational because the 'willingness to pay' of some billionaires for the almost arbitrary early access to a vaccine which will soon be cheap and plentiful ... works well as a 'win win' both for the buyer, and society.

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#556
post #451
post #211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay, please explain the science that people are following. As for the one bad situation, please take a look at this list - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_pharmaceutic... . this is the top 20.

I'm not going to explain how clinical trials work and why you should trust that process. Again, bad situations do not invalidate all work being done in a field.

Why would you not explain this? By explaining it you answer the question. It seems like a strange thing not to explain?

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#557
The problem with this question is that there are likely to be multiple vaccines. Each will have its quirks.

The first round of vaccines will require two doses a few weeks apart. Each one of those requires a visit. Failure to get the second shot will likely lead to severely reduced efficacy.

The first two vaccines likely to be available in the US will be mRNA vaccines. They are based on an entirely new platform that's never been deployed at scale. That's going to lead to some surprises - possibly good but maybe not so good.

Later vaccines will be more traditional such as the adenovirus-based vaccine being developed by J&J.

Numerically, we're likely to see severe reactions or even death in hundreds or thousands of cases at least. The clinical trials are being run on tens of thousands of patients only, and can only pick up so many reactions. As hundreds of millions get vaccinated, we'll see the full range of effects, some of which could be serious even with the safest vaccines. It's important to keep this in perspective as the news of incidents starts to come out.

I sometimes hear the statement "I'm waiting until it's proven safe." If that's you, you might want to ask yourself what evidence you'll need to know the vaccine is safe.

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#558

I voted WILL WAIT simply because the idea of becoming Will Smith in my own "I Am Legend" city is appealing.

Unfortunately you'll end up stuck in there with mostly anti-vaxxers

Keep in mind that Coronavirus vaccine are novel and not field tested, whereas other vaccines are field tested for decades.

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#559
post #318
post #129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"So much faith"? People are just following the science. Are you really arguing that because one bad situation has occurred involving pharmaceutical companies, we should assume every new drug or treatment is bogus or based on evil motives?

In 2020 there’s science and The Science. The latter seems to be more religious in its application and what it means to its devotees. That makes life difficult.

I don't think it's religious per say but it is definitely ingrained in the my team Vs the other mentality us humans seem to have

Re: Poll: Will you take the Covid vaccine?

#560
Here is where risk analysis come in. Lower chance of vaccine rare side effect short term vs long term and vs getting Covid in those periods, which also has its own set of less rare side effects.

The best bet is get it the fist chance you are offered it as most people won’t get it right away and you will already see most of the effects.

Post reply on HN