Live data from Hacker News

Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

annas-archive.org

541–550 of 560 posts

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#541

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's complicated. Many years ago, I was involved in a movie release group. Pretty much everybody in that group owned more VHSs/DVDs than the typical person. This is probably not surprising, since the time and effort one needs to put into that is rather large. Those who only downloaded were more of a mixed bag; some of them were not in the US and might not be able to see a domestic release of the movies any time soon.…

I spent a small fortune on a record collection. Then the record format was abandoned and it was all CDs. I spent a small fortune re-buying that same record collection, insofar as the records were even available as CDs. Then we went all digital (yes, I know CDs were already digital) and it became MP3s. So I ripped my CD collection and assigned them to a box in my attic. I will not be spending money on spotify or whate…

[dead]

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#542

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No honour among thieves.

Let’s have the person who does not use any LLMs throw the first stone.

Will OpenAI get mad if I use text produced by ChatGPT? Will they say I stole it?

Then why does AA get mad that somebody else steals the material that AA stole in the first place?

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#543

Isn't it humorous how citizens are pro Anna's archive, but governments are against it? Bit of additional evidence for elitism and such.

It is neither humorous nor strange because that formulation omits authors . How many authors who write the books in Anna's archive are happy about it? I personally am pro Anna's archive (and sci-hub, etc) because I believe it benefits society to have better-read citizens. That said, I have some misgivings, because under our current system, there are issues with law and remuneration.

I know one popular author who doesn't care: Brandon Sanderson. In addition he makes it possible to buy DRM free ebooks from his website.

In his words: “My experience has been that readers want to support things they like … But if they are at a point in their lives where they can’t, then it’s better to let them read the stories they want … and let them support artists when they’re capable of it. So I am a big fan of giving away books for free.”

Source: https://www.jotdown.es/2016/12/brandon-sanderson-i-want-to-s...

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#544
post #459

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are there any links you could share for.. ..ehm.. ..research purposes?

I've downloaded a few from yggtorrent, but there might be some more niche/less public sites I'm not aware of

You were not supposed to spoil the website behind my #WONTTELL hashtag ;)

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#545
post #361

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The french comic pirate scene has an interesting rule where they keep a ~6 month time lag on what they release. The scene is small enough that the rule generally works. It's a really good trade-off. I would never have gotten into these comics without piracy but now if something catches my eye, I don't mind buying on release (and stripping the DRM for personal use). Most of my downloading is closer to collecting/hoard…

So copyright just with a shorter time limit?

The fact is that those comics are sometimes not available AT ALL anywhere apart from eBay (or equivalent). It is alreadu VERY tricky to learn that those items exist. And then, determining their value for you is simply not possible without those kind of "alternative" delivery solutions [aka piracy].

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#546

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends a bit probably if your local library has major lawsuits for operating in a very sketchy side of the legal gray area

Maybe your library shouldn't have made choices that put it at odds with the data preservation community then.

Strongly agree, but what does that have to do with the point I was making: that yes indeed they might be liable, and are different than a library?

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#547
post #448

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Luckily it isn't the only public DNS. 8.8.8.8, 9.9.9.9, and many others exist.

Here it's Cloudflare the CDN, sitting in front of Anna's Archive, that's doing the blocking. The DNS resolver used doesn't come into play. (Case in point, I am using Google's DNS, yet still encounter the block when accessing from a Belgian IP.)

Touché!

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#548
post #262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then what's the economic interest for writing a book

Very little. Aside from high-profile/best-selling authors who do make a decent amount of money, the vast majority of writers do it because they love doing it, not because they expect to become rich.

Now you can publish independently through Kindle or through learnpub. Would that not cut out the intermediary fees?

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#549

Fuck that site. Offers people links to free PDF downloads of my book that I worked on for 32 years and finally got published by Pantheon Books in 2017. I didn't work all that fucking time for criminals like these to just break copyright law and make the book available for free. Fuck Anna's Archive, and I hope they go down in legal flames ASAP.

[flagged]

What an asshole.

Re: Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team

#550

Fuck that site. Offers people links to free PDF downloads of my book that I worked on for 32 years and finally got published by Pantheon Books in 2017. I didn't work all that fucking time for criminals like these to just break copyright law and make the book available for free. Fuck Anna's Archive, and I hope they go down in legal flames ASAP.

It may be a minority, but not all authors share your view. Paulo Coelho [1] says “a person who does not share is not only selfish, but bitter and alone”. Sorry gotta say it, your tone matches. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paulo_Coelho

LOL, whatever.
Post reply on HN