Live data from Hacker News

Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

axios.com

541–550 of 562 posts

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#541

I feel like the good faith presumption for this company has to have shifted by now. Is there any reason not to assume that the Chinese government is surveilling Zoom calls en masse? Documenting participants (face, voice, language, location, etc.), recording content, etc. We're talking about the data of 200M+ users. I see people on HN defending Zoom all the time. >The company has acknowledged that much of its product…

[deleted]

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#542
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I generally share a smattering of links like these: Zoom banned from New York City schools due to privacy and security flaws https://www.fastcompany.com/90486586/zoom-banned-from-new-yo... Google Told Its Workers That They Can’t Use Zoom On Their Laptops Anymore https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/pranavdixit/google-bans... Elon Musk's SpaceX bans Zoom over privacy concerns https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-…

I relied on Mozilla's guide and they seem to be perfectly OK with recommending Zoom as a video conferencing app https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/categor...

This is very interesting. I do trust mozilla. However many of the security concerns stem from the dubious thing the Zoom installer does, which Mozilla's scorecard does not cover. I feel a little more at east with a Mozilla recommendation, however.

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#543
post #246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A Whereby-developer here. It's awesome you recommend us. You can turn on "mobile mode" in advanced device settings, and it should be a bit better. But we're a bit limited in how CPU-friendly we really can be, living in the browser. Not that we can't improve, there's certainly extra tricks we could try - but not easily without also lowering fps and resolution. I don't think "low resource use" is a big selling-argument…

Nice! Fellow Scandinavian here. Just some feedback. I think the free tier was a little unclear. > Free > Personal use > 1 user > 1 meeting room I have trouble reading this. It's as if I coule only create one room for myself without having anybody to chat with.

Hehe, I see. Yeah copy and marketing is hard. I think we should try to re-do that one. It's hard to get right for all cases.

A p2p room can have 4 total people in it. So say you plus 3 concurrent guests, none of those guests need any account or "user".

Indeed even you don't have to log in after you've created the room if you leave it unlocked. :)

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#544
post #246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A Whereby-developer here. It's awesome you recommend us. You can turn on "mobile mode" in advanced device settings, and it should be a bit better. But we're a bit limited in how CPU-friendly we really can be, living in the browser. Not that we can't improve, there's certainly extra tricks we could try - but not easily without also lowering fps and resolution. I don't think "low resource use" is a big selling-argument…

Hey! I've been using Whereby at work for a while and it's great. However, I should mention that it's not possible to join calls through the mobile app (as far as I can tell), and the web app on mobile wouldn't capture my Bluetooth headset's audio properly somehow. Again, thanks for the great work. Just thought I'd let you know :)

Thanks! It is very valuable with feedback like this, even if in this case we're painfully aware of it. :)

I was working on fixing up that when COVID-19 hit. Now we're trying to stamp out more obscure audio+video bugs (like bluetooth, which can be unreliable). We're in process of hiring a few more people so we can hopefully put someone on caring more for the non-logged in mobile app experience.

You do get a join button once you've logged in. But I must confess it is not a good experience by default. It used to be on the top of the priority list, but then scaling and any video/audio issues jumped to the top.

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#545

I feel like the good faith presumption for this company has to have shifted by now. Is there any reason not to assume that the Chinese government is surveilling Zoom calls en masse? Documenting participants (face, voice, language, location, etc.), recording content, etc. We're talking about the data of 200M+ users. I see people on HN defending Zoom all the time. >The company has acknowledged that much of its product…

> recording content, etc.

Would it be technically feasible to record everything?

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#546
post #351

Earlier quoted context omitted.

China has been accused a number of times of engaging in industrial espionage. As a company developing a lot of high technology products, I think Google is entirely justified in keep Zoom out of its technology infrastructure.

If it wasn't clear, I was just being sarcastic about Google's huge number of messaging products... I fully agree with your statement, their move totally makes sense from an IP protection standpoint.

It's three products but it has 27 different names.

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#547
post #544

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey! I've been using Whereby at work for a while and it's great. However, I should mention that it's not possible to join calls through the mobile app (as far as I can tell), and the web app on mobile wouldn't capture my Bluetooth headset's audio properly somehow. Again, thanks for the great work. Just thought I'd let you know :)

Thanks! It is very valuable with feedback like this, even if in this case we're painfully aware of it. :) I was working on fixing up that when COVID-19 hit. Now we're trying to stamp out more obscure audio+video bugs (like bluetooth, which can be unreliable). We're in process of hiring a few more people so we can hopefully put someone on caring more for the non-logged in mobile app experience. You do get a join butto…

Awesome. Keep up the good work :)

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#548

I wonder if we'll hear the "they're a private company, they can do what they want, it is only censorship if the government does it" routine. I remember about a decade ago when certain parties were so concerned with voices being silenced and "erasure." The same people are now cheering when Facebook, Twitter, and the like shut down certain kinds of speech, with great discretion as to how the "rules" are implemented. Th…

Isn't the base argument is tolerance/inclusivity good, intolerance bad. (Intolerance like inciting violence, suppressing criticism, homophobia, xenophobia, bigotry, the usual.) And simply taking steps that make make the world better according to this base argument is also good?

This of course can become slippery and slope-y eventually, if a propaganda machine takes over as the tolerance authority, but I don't think that's a real problem compared to what the other problems the argument is trying to address.

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#549
post #282

I feel like the good faith presumption for this company has to have shifted by now. Is there any reason not to assume that the Chinese government is surveilling Zoom calls en masse? Documenting participants (face, voice, language, location, etc.), recording content, etc. We're talking about the data of 200M+ users. I see people on HN defending Zoom all the time. >The company has acknowledged that much of its product…

> Is there any reason not to assume that the Chinese government is surveilling Zoom calls en masse? It makes perfect sense to boycott Zoom based on their security issues, but does the presumption of innocence mean nothing anymore? It shouldn't be difficult to prove that Zoom is actively trying to block Chinese activists. China banned Zoom during the trade war. Are you going to treat that as evidence that Zoom isn't c…

Don't want to sound I'm defending Zoom or CCP, but how does en masse surveillance work technically in this case? How practical it is to go over all the voice data (not manually I presume)? Text based mining and censoring is possible but there still is a huge gap and language expertise isn't cheap. I might be missing a few references but it'll be great if someone could point me to these links.

Re: Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event

#550
post #246
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You could give Whereby [1] a try. I really liked it when it was named "appear.in" (that's now a completely different company), and used it for a bit, until my work switched to Teams. Whereby is, as far as I can tell, completely owned by a Norwegian registered company. 1: https://whereby.com

A Whereby-developer here. It's awesome you recommend us. You can turn on "mobile mode" in advanced device settings, and it should be a bit better. But we're a bit limited in how CPU-friendly we really can be, living in the browser. Not that we can't improve, there's certainly extra tricks we could try - but not easily without also lowering fps and resolution. I don't think "low resource use" is a big selling-argument…

Does mobile mode enable VP9?
Post reply on HN