Live data from Hacker News

Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

sparktoro.com

521–530 of 531 posts

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#521

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And the downfall of AOL was Google because Google had a better product. In order for google to fall, you need a product that's better (or more of what people want; you need to give them a reason to change their search engine).

... and that product will likely repeat the cycle again, on some schedule of another. Might be the 20+ years of Google, might be the few years that Medium was only modestly annoying, might instantly go to shit. The problem is the business model breeds for this, and we end up replacing one abusive monopoly with another, until we can break that cycle. For a time it seemed Free Software might ... free us ... from that,…

Searching symptom tracker, google tells me no no you mean symptom checker. No sorry I do need a way to track them not check them

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#522
post #15

So a common trope in the startup world is the difference between a feature and a company, the idea being that lots of features are masquerading as companies. This inevitably leads to them being shocked--SHOCKED--when some bigger player adds that feature, eating their lunch. I feel the same way about a lot of outbound sites on Google. There are a bunch of things I just don't want to go to another site for. Off the top…

I understand your stand, but what Google did with its featured snippets is essentially a form of bait and switch. It encouraged entrepreneurs and creators to create content that could answer specific queries with the promise that Google will drive traffic to their sites. Now Google is using the same content and depriving them of the traffic. That's pretty scummy in my opinion.

Facebook did this with pages

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#523
post #161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I want exchange rates I type xe.com in the address bar

For an increasing proportion of users, the "address bar" is now the "Google search" bar. You may have discovered xe.com when the distinction was much more obvious, but as time went on the browser UI underwent changes, that will change as well. New versions of Chromium will begin hiding the full URL entirely, probably so that more and more marketing/targeting related UTM parameters can be jammed in without the user ev…

No it’s so you don’t remember it or care for urls and just search everything making google the only source of info online.

Pay to play baby if you want to show up

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#524

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't have to prove anything to opt out of indexing.

And in the lyrics case, it wouldn't have helped because Google wasn't scraping the lyrics. Google was paying a third party that copied the Genius site.

So it’s a multilayered problem, and content owners are on the losing side.

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#525
post #202

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/database.html#data This doesn't provide any protection for the underlying facts.

No, but if Google imports a database then they are still affected by the compilation copyright. It's too obvious of a hack to "just" claim that "yeah, we imported that entire database, but then we cracked all the facts apart and they're all separate now and it's just as if we never imported the database". That's not how the law works. Even more interestingly, we've still never yet resolved the question of why Google…

I'd rather give up copyright than search engines. Anyone who wants to push too hard ought to consider whether an entire nation might make the same choice.

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#526
post #496

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Googlebot actually used to support a noindex rule in robots.txt, but they are removing it. https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2019/07/a-note-on-unsuppor...

Yes, that was linked above. It looks like this is part of reducing support to what's in the spec?

Oops, yep. I didn't see that context.

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#527

I think what folks are missing is that a lot of these "zero-click" searches happen as a result of Google scraping your website, and displaying the results as a "featured snippet." Yes, they link to you below the featured snippet. No, more people don't click, because they've taken the answer from your website and displayed it right in their search results. For example: If I'm searching for "best nail for cedar wood" G…

It's important to note that this is strategically incredibly important for Google because this forms the backbone of their voice AI. The better at answering questions directly, the better their voice AI becomes and that leads to a lot of future products.

Then the snippet should just be used for voice search. And websites should opt in to the program.

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#528

I think what folks are missing is that a lot of these "zero-click" searches happen as a result of Google scraping your website, and displaying the results as a "featured snippet." Yes, they link to you below the featured snippet. No, more people don't click, because they've taken the answer from your website and displayed it right in their search results. For example: If I'm searching for "best nail for cedar wood" G…

I do a fair amount of grammar and spelling searches. Google often displays tips and examples. And typing "sp500" displays a stock chart right in Google itself. Google has a lot of "instant snippets" like that. Quite convenient. However, near-monopolies do make me nervous about supporting them.

Re: Fewer Than Half of Google Searches Now Result in a Click

#529

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a faustian bargin. Google is so powerful you can't do without them, but they're also inexorably eating your future.

Google is so powerful you can't do without them I wonder how true that assumption really is any more. The quality of traffic Google drives to sites I operate is very low compared to all other major sources, with much less engagement by any metric you like, notably including conversions. The only reliable exception is when we're running marketing campaigns in other places, which often result in spikes in both direct v…

It is a very significant part of our business.
Post reply on HN