Live data from Hacker News

As I lay dying: Final op-ed from LA Times journalist Laurie Beckland

latimes.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: As I lay dying: Final op-ed from LA Times journalist Laurie Beckland

#51

Excerpt: We now know that breast cancer is not one disease. What works for one person might not for another: There is no one “cure.” We are each, in effect, one-person clinical trials. Yet the knowledge generated from those trials will die with us because there is no comprehensive database of metastatic breast cancer patients, their characteristics and what treatments did and didn't help them. In the Big Data-era, th…

Government regulation of how your personal information is created and stored makes such a database infeasibly difficult to create and maintain. The regulation is good, in that it protects an individual's privacy from those who could harm them with it (for example, the insurance industry, the paparazzi, your employers), but it also harms initiatives which aim only for good. Unfortunately, we have to account for the wo…

This partly true, though HIPAA is more of a burden because of people's misunderstanding of it than what it actually mandates.

However, I posit that it is a lack of government regulation that has allowed health IT vendors to take no responsibility for supporting standards that enable data sharing across care settings. Every person in ill health deserves better study and care than we currently provide.

These problems are indeed well understood by some of us in healthcare, the details of a US 'Interoperability Roadmap' are available at the below link. Please take a moment to see where we are now, where we are headed, and how you might contribute.

http://www.healthit.gov/sites/default/files/nationwide-inter...

Re: As I lay dying: Final op-ed from LA Times journalist Laurie Beckland

#52
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a pretty transparent attempt at reverse psychology, and a form of vote-begging. Intstead try, "I hope I don't offend anyone by saying this, but..."

I can see how it's perceived that way. Fwiw, that was my frustration of down votes for unpopular, well meaning, statements. Thank you for the communication & attitude tip. I'll adopt it.

Never discuss downvoting in the comments. Do not complain about them. Do not anticipate them. Do not ask for them. Anyone who says anything often enough will suffer downvotes at some point. If you can't figure out why, then ignore it.

Last two paragraphs:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

There are exceptions, like a legitimate meta-discussion about the karma system, but those should be vanishingly rare.

Post reply on HN