Live data from Hacker News

The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

cambridge.org

51–60 of 98 posts

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#51

I have a MS in CSCI, PhD in cognitive psych, but know nothing at all about electronics. Is this a reasonable first book? I ask bc somebody compared it to TAOCP which I would not recommend to somebody with zero CSCI/programming skills. EDIT: thanks for the feedback, I'll look elsewhere to get my feet wet.

I disagree with the below and would recommend this book.

See my other comment on this thread for more details. But basically I took Physics 123 at Harvard, and AoE sprang from the professor's lecture notes. When I took the class in the late 90's, It was taught by Horowiz and Hayes, as Hill had left previously to do his own thing.

The class had many people from non-hard-science disciplines who didn't know anything about electronics. I specifically remember a couple of psych students. They all did great, see comment above on what we build at the ends of the analog and digital halves of a one-semester course.

The student lab manual written by Horowiz and Hayes, from which we did our class labs, also gives great context and a hands-on plan to learning the material.

I also knew a few artists in the Boston scene that used this book to build actual electronic items for performance art shows, including robo-mechanical drum machines and analog synths.

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#52
I always wanted a copy of this when it was recommended on my Comp Sys Engineering B.Eng but never could afford it at the time.

I'm tempted to buy a copy now even though the closest I get to electronics these days is configuring my router.

//edit//$120! It was £20 when it was recommended on my course in 1990 (IIRC).

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#53

This is offtopic, but I need to ask this question and I fear I may loose the opportunity to field it to this audience of experts. I'm interested in two things and am wondering if this book, or something else, would be of use to me. Assume I have strong math background, and assume I understand the Maxwell equations. What book/resource provides a good understanding of the approximations (from first principles) needed t…

I can only direct you to the simulation package we used at university, I have no idea if it is the best, but it was fairly good during the time of my studies.

http://www.sonnetsoftware.com/

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#54
post #7

Hope it's for real this time. It was supposed to be out in early 2014 http://www.eevblog.com/forum/chat/the-art-of-electronics-3rd...

Sounds like it. Win Hill mentioned on Usenet a few weeks ago that it was really done and in the hands of the publisher.

I can't wait to get my hands on it.

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#55
post #44

Can someone with no electronics background at all pick up this book? If not what would be a good prerequisite book?

Yes, that's basically the purpose of this book. Though amazingly experts will also learn many things and find it useful too. I took the Physics 123 class at Harvard, from which this book developed from the original course notes, and uses this as the textbook (the class is still taught by Horowitz who has encyclopediac knowledge of electronics and Hayes who replaced Hill when he left Harvard. These guys also wrote the…

Thanks for that I am getting into ardunio and was looking for good textbook - I have basic electronics back from my engineeing ONC and need sligly more up to date book than the priciples of wireless that I inherited from my dad - pre transistor age and still referes to capacitors as condensors :-)

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some of the parts discussed are probably in wide use because they are mentioned in AoE. The uA741 effect.

That was basically the only opamp we were allowed to use in my undergraduate electronics for Physicists classes.

It's a terrible opamp for precision measurement. (Actually it's a terrible opamp for most things, except maybe student experiments.)

I have mixed feelings about AofA.

On the one hand it's funny and a good broad introduction to a lot of relevant concepts.

On the other it glosses over so much of the math you need to learn to be competent at design that it doesn't teach you nearly as much as it seems to.

When I first read it as an electronic engineering undergrad I thought this was a very good thing, especially compared to the standard textbooks that buried you in equations.

A few decades later I'm not so convinced. I think a good upgrade would be a series of much bigger books (or Wiki pages?) that keep the breezy hands-on style but also dig fearlessly into the details.

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#58
The Art of Electronics, combined with the Student Workbook are excellent books to teach yourself electronics.

I guess today you'd use electronic simulations on a computer rather than real components on bread-boards with real test equipment. Perhaps some HNer is involved with this type of simulation software? I might be worth creating "labs" that can be used while reading tAoE?

Re: The Art of Electronics, 3rd Edition, to be released April 2015

#59
post #57

Own this book previous edition. What is good resources for learning electronics online? Are the online schools like Codeschool and Codeacademy with tutorials anywhere that are good that you can recommend?

There usually are few electronic related courses on Coursera. Haven't done any of them yet, but I'm satisfied with the quality of their other courses. Check "engineering" category here:

https://www.coursera.org/courses?languages=en&categories=ee

Post reply on HN