Live data from Hacker News

Gmail blocked in China

reuters.com

51–60 of 190 posts

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#51
post #46

I live in Urumqi. Not only Gmail is blocked , but all the google services are blocked here. And it has been quite a long time.

I'm looking to ride through west china this summer. Would I be able to send you an email / IM to ask a few logistical questions? :)

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#52
Perhaps we are an edge case, but this has a potentially significant impact to certain businesses, namingly those that are Google Apps customers and rely on gmail to get work done. They'll be routing all web traffic over their own network via HK or Singapore, but...

That doesn't help employees who need Mobile email access. As of now, companies can't count on remote access to corporate gmail by Chinese employees. We have about 2500 Chinese employees with sanctioned BYOD phones - it's a huge problem!

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why doesn't my tunnel work in China?

The issue is that Google's mail servers can't communicate with servers within China, so any user of a Chinese mail service will not be able to send mail to Gmail users (and vice versa). If you are within China using a VPN to access Gmail, Google still can't send emails back in to Chinese machines.

Ah. Seems dumb of them. There are millions of Chinese people all around the world that will be trying to email their family back home. Why block just one email provider? Why try to segregate yourself from the world's email network? It isn't even going to work because what every Chinese person will do is get a tunnel to sign up for the non-Chinese email service (maybe even Gmail!) and it will just further push people to use encryption.

If the Chinese government were shrewd, they would do what the American government does: make using American servers as easy as possible then spy on the contents.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#54

Travelling in China right now. No Google services work but Gmail via SMTP on my iPhone seems fine. I'm not confident all emails go through though. Heading to Hong Kong tonight so not sure if that will be different. Using VPN does open everything but obviously becomes slower. It's not only Google though, all social media. Speaking to locals they don't care. There is an alternative for everything and they are better su…

>There is an alternative for everything and they are better suited to Chinese culture too. Well good for them, either way with this policy the Chinese government enforces, I don't think China will be able to compete internationally in the software industry.

> I don't think China will be able to compete internationally in the software industry.

That is a very self-centered point of view, in recent european TED talks there were speakers like Mikko Hypponen from F-Secure, that there should be "european" versions of Google, Facebook, so we can avoid all the dragnet datamining etc. unethical web development solutions and NSA spying that somehow pass in the US.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#55
post #50
post #46

I live in Urumqi. Not only Gmail is blocked , but all the google services are blocked here. And it has been quite a long time.

Are you a foreigner or are you Chinese? I'm curious as I naively assumed that due to the unrest\resistance that even tourism in Urumqi was difficult to do legally, and therefore residence\work would be out of the question or nigh on impossible

I'm Chinese, but I am from minority. I am a developer so it is quite painful to live with this network.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#56

What do citizens in China think of this? When Google Search was effectively banned, some scientists said that they depended on Google Scholar and Google Books, services which were also affected by the ban. Are Baidu and similar services really an effective replacement? I'm also wondering what would happen if the U.S. takes this to the World Trade Organization. Arbitrarily blocking some company's services could well b…

Thanks to GFW, many of my friends learned the usage of VPN/SSH/NAT/hosts at a very early age, which benefits a lot when taking computer network course. (>﹏<.)

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#57
post #51
post #46

I live in Urumqi. Not only Gmail is blocked , but all the google services are blocked here. And it has been quite a long time.

I'm looking to ride through west china this summer. Would I be able to send you an email / IM to ask a few logistical questions? :)

Sure. I am happy to help . I can access Gmail with SOCKS proxy, so you can mail me at a p h a w k.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#58

Travelling in China right now. No Google services work but Gmail via SMTP on my iPhone seems fine. I'm not confident all emails go through though. Heading to Hong Kong tonight so not sure if that will be different. Using VPN does open everything but obviously becomes slower. It's not only Google though, all social media. Speaking to locals they don't care. There is an alternative for everything and they are better su…

"They don't care??!!" There are 1.3 billion Chinese and half of them use the Internet, how many locals you have spoken with? I live in China and am in the IT industry, I know there are a lot people quit using Gmail because the ban, not to say Google Search.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>There is an alternative for everything and they are better suited to Chinese culture too. Well good for them, either way with this policy the Chinese government enforces, I don't think China will be able to compete internationally in the software industry.

> I don't think China will be able to compete internationally in the software industry. That is a very self-centered point of view, in recent european TED talks there were speakers like Mikko Hypponen from F-Secure, that there should be "european" versions of Google, Facebook, so we can avoid all the dragnet datamining etc. unethical web development solutions and NSA spying that somehow pass in the US.

If such products are created and succeed, it will be because they competed well with their American counterparts. The equivalent Chinese products don't face any competition at all.

Re: Gmail blocked in China

#60
post #44

The sentiment that access to Google services doesn't matter because there are sufficient Chinese replacements is absolutely wrong. The Chinese government is handicapping its tech labor development by blocking Google. I teach a basic web development workshop to university and vocational school students. One of the things we teach is how to look up things for youself on the internet. (Is that a cry of disbelief I hear?…

This is correct. While it's a minority, all the Chinese programmers (me included) hate the GFW!
Post reply on HN