Earlier quoted context omitted.
It looks like a combination of (social) search, OneNote & PowerPoint. It seems to let you find, store and organize information. Then you may also format it for presenting. That's what I got from the ad anyway.
When I first saw and started using OneNote it was a beautiful experience and felt so different from every other Microsoft product. So far, Sway could have that feel do if they do it right.
Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
51–60 of 139 posts
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#52I got a feeling that MS reinvented Google Wave... maybe they can do it correctly this time.
Apache Wave is an attempt at an email replacement. Something akin to Facebook Messanger but with more hooks into extensions (kind of like Sharepoint meets Facebook Messenger).
This product is more a publisher-like application, create stuff then share it, not a real time communications application.
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#53Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#54Earlier quoted context omitted.
A lot of startups use this tactic, it's not uncommon. The email clearly says you're on the list, if you don't like waiting, tweet about it. What's wrong with that?
What's wrong with it? It irritates the consumer by making you feel like you are being played with. It really turned me off.
Thanks for signing up for an invite to join Sway Preview. We've reserved a spot for you.
Hate to wait? Follow us and tweet why you're excited to use Sway, for a chance at earlier access.
I would give out invites first to people telling the world why they're excited to use my product. It's better for my product, really, what's wrong with it? They don't force you to tweet to get an invite, that would be different (and tactically, but not morally, wrong).
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#55If I'm not mistaken Microsoft is In the phone business too...
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#56It looks like we're in a general upward trend of richer interactive documents created by average users.
Some observations of the zeitgiest that look unrelated on the surface but nevertheless, seems to point towards a common desire for dynamic user-controlled "documents":
-- Javascript d3.js embedded in stories, blog articles, etc that engages readers to "play" with data (Mike Bostock is a good example of interactive pictures for New York Times) [1],[2]
-- Mathematica CDF (Computable Document Format) with things like sliders, etc to let the user control how the data changes[3]
-- Bret Victor's various demonstrations for dynamic content [4]
-- many more examples, etc. I cant remember but play on this theme
Right now, there isn't an interactive document format (or interactive content creation tool) that dominates the way Microsoft PowerPoint dominates for the old-style static stuff.
If one has the skills, one can write d3.js type presentations but obviously, the typical PowerPoint jock isn't not going to learn javascript like Mike Bostock.
Before d3.js, if I personally wanted to write any interactive charts for presentation and embed that interactivity inside a document that managers could review offline, I'd create an Excel spreadsheet + add some GUI slider controls + add some Visual Basic code to react to sliders to update the spreadsheet.[5] Unfortunately, any xls (xlsm) file with a macro throws up all sorts of scary security warnings when a user open the xls file. It's just very clunky to share this type of doc.
It's hard to tell from the demo, but it seems like Sway is also a tool to author content intended for non-linear exploration. (Whereas PowerPoint or MS Word docs are consumed in linear fashion ... PgDn, Pgdn, etc). Therefore, some of its features would overlap with an eLearning-creation tool like Adobe Captivate[6].
In short, I believe the market is trying to sort out how to empower averager users to make dynamic presentation content. The d3.js, the Excel macros, the Mathematica CDF, etc are tools that are too specialized and meant for experts. This is why the demo commercial emphasized a young child creating materials instead of an adult programming expert. It's the "so easy a child could do it" type of narrative.
I can't tell from the demo if the content created would be 100% cloud stored and delivered. I would think that Sway would also have the capability to create self-contained document files. I can think of big customer like the USA government not using it if it's cloud only. The government loves their Powerpoint presentations. The government also has tons of locked down computers without internet access that share Powerpoints so a 100% cloud-Sway product would be a no-go.
EDIT ADD: after looking at sway website again, I finally noticed that they have 6 example Sway presentations ("Sways we love"). None of those examples have any interactive data features that I could detect. On the other hand, the video @ 34 secs shows the woman manipulating a chart. The 6 example docs are not that impressive; they just look like a bunch of jquery sliding animations instead of representing the dynamics I see in the video. Maybe I'm overestimating what Sway actually can do. If it's just a program with a bunch of themes for sliding animations and adjustable grids that resize to desktop or mobile screens, that would be a huge disappointment.
[2]https://github.com/mbostock/d3/wiki/Gallery
[3]http://reference.wolfram.com/language/howto/CreateAComputabl...
[4]http://worrydream.com/#!/MediaForThinkingTheUnthinkable
[5]http://chandoo.org/wp/2013/08/06/how-to-create-a-then-vs-now...
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#57Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#581. Interesting that they showed an Apple logo on the back of the iPad (it would be hard to hide that it was an iPad), but no evidence whatsoever of any Microsoft mobile device (does a laptop count?) 2. I kinda want that umbrella.
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#59Earlier quoted context omitted.
What's wrong with it? It irritates the consumer by making you feel like you are being played with. It really turned me off.
Here's the text: Thanks for signing up for an invite to join Sway Preview. We've reserved a spot for you. Hate to wait? Follow us and tweet why you're excited to use Sway, for a chance at earlier access. I would give out invites first to people telling the world why they're excited to use my product. It's better for my product, really, what's wrong with it? They don't force you to tweet to get an invite, that would b…
I think that's it. Asking me for free advertising for a product I haven't even had the chance to use feels like you just want to use me to promote your product, no one wants to feel used even if that means getting something out of it.
Re: Sway: A new presentation application from Microsoft
#60Ad seems a tad optimistic given the examples you can view are kind of awful. I get that not everything is going to be professional and polished when it hits the real world, but this can't be one of your three "sways we love" at product launch: https://sway.com/red_panda