Live data from Hacker News

Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

webpagesthatsuck.com

51–56 of 56 posts

Re: Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

#51
post #20

I think #2 should be #1, it is insane on how many people can not articulate what their website is about in a sentence or two. It becomes so frustrating for a brand new user to visit a website and reads a bunch of marketing gibberish. Sometimes I think that a good test would be to have a 7 year old come to home page of the website. Let him look around and then report back to you what the website is about. :)

Absolutely a HUGE gripe of mine.

I spun out a quick rant on HN some time back which became among my most popular comments of all time. Eventually posted it as an article on its on, "Please Forward to Marketing":

http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/27d5xr/please_f...

Tell me what the fuck it is EVERY GODDAMNED TIME YOU COMMUNICATE ABOUT THE PRODUCT. It doesn't have to be long or detailed, you can link to your detailed description in the communication. But your press releases, emails, Tweets, blog posts, marketing collateral, etc., are going to get passed around, word-of-mouthed, and/or pulled out of drawers (or browser history / searches) for weeks, months, and years to come. Make them work for you. A link back to your primary site should be present where at all possible -- in your Twitter profile if not the Tweet itself. Absolutely include links to your primary site from blog posts.

.... and more.

Re: Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

#52

While many, if not all statements made there are true, the page seems to be adding the biggest mistake itself: The virtual tag-line is apparently, "How to make a flashing website, if you've nothing to say and no intention to do so, but for your interest in making money from it." (At least for me, this is oozing through most of the lines, since there is seemingly no notion of any interest behind engaging in a website…

You're not reading the piece well in this case.

First point: "These women are laughing at you. Why? You designed your website for your needs, not theirs."

Write these two sentences where you can see them as you're working:

1. The only reason my website exists is to solve my customers' problems.

2. What problems does the page I'm looking at solve?

If your interest is in providing an informational site (as mine typically is), then the problem you're addressing is "what information is my reader looking for, how can I convince them that I'm satisfying it, and then satisfy it?".

Re: Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

#54
post #24

I think fixed menus and the like popping up all over the place deserves to be in there. I often resort to 'inspect element' and the delete key to be rid of them.

Stylebot and element inspector. I've got ~2000 site-specific stylesheets to address annoyances such as this.

I find visiting websites without my set of CSS mods extremely painful.

Readability (or similar services) aren't a bad substitute.

Web design isn't the solution, web design is the problem.

Re: Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

#55
post #12

Not mentioned: using a large font size so each line contains only five words. For example, webpagesthatsuck.com does this.

Sadly, sizing fonts such that they're universally appropriate is difficult. Building a site which defaults to the user's preferred font size (though this often isn't set), and otherwise scales up and down in size, helps.

I find setting the main body to a 45em width, with 4em padding, and auto margins, is pretty close to perfect (desktop/laptop).

Re: Biggest Mistakes in Web Design 1995-2015

#56
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You did back then.

Javascript was very popular for drop-down menu ever since Netscape Navigator 2 and IE 3 (DHTML). Java applets were a lot less common. Macromedia's Flash 5/MX took over that Java applet marketshare around 2000.

Yeah, GP said "dont need JS or applets", but you did indeed need JS.
Post reply on HN