Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

pickfu.com

51–60 of 72 posts

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To take the other side...there is currently a beautiful simplicity about this idea and execution. I pretty much just fall asleep when I start trying to deal with A/B testing, market research, ad effectiveness, etc. This is so simple that all I have to ask myself is, "Do I have a question I'd like to ask a bunch of people?" and "Do I have five dollars?" That's a really good place to be, because everybody in business h…

Fair enough... but if this is just a completely random, not-even-remotely-scientific man on the street approach, then what problem does this solve that a poll i can add to my website/blog/favorite forum via Fantastico in 180 seconds doesn't?

Example: I am designing a logo for a market research site. I put up the pickfu logo against mine (or just use two of mine), & ask users which company does market research.

Examples 2-100: A poll on my site or blog would work fine but... I don't want people on my site to know what I'm polling. I don't have a site. I don't know how to do polls on my site. My IT department says it will take 8 weeks. My web design guys say they don't have the module for this particular CMS - they can build one from scratch for $2k. I told the web design guys to go to hell & found an embeddable polling service, it'll take 4 weeks & they won't be responsible if it doesn't work. I worked it out with the web design guys but my boss says we need to use the companies standard colour scheme - the widget won't change its colour.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#52
post #21

Wow, this is pretty upsetting because I have been working on the exact same idea as you. How long has it been up, what kind of volume have you been doing, and how long did it take you to make it?

How about change "upsetting" to "motivating" and you're good. The world is a big place, and competitors mean the market exists.

Competitors doesn't mean a significant market exists, it means multiple people have come up with the idea.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#53

My first thought: Why can't I answer the questions? I know you're going to say something along the lines of "we want to ensure that users are unique, and demographically diverse, blah blah blah." Yeah, I know, but still. When I see "Mac or PC", I instinctively click on the "Mac" option, and when nothing happens, I think "Well, THAT's clearly broken!" I know you probably don't want to create just another hot-or-not si…

Good idea. We've heard similar feedback before but haven't had a chance to get around to it. We'll revisit it.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#54
post #42

Impressive! Keep up the good work. Just wondering, how has RPX ( https://rpxnow.com/ ) Login outsourcing/integration worked for you guys? Would you recommend it highly? Edit: Btw, the Yahoo OpenId login prompts: "Warning: pickfu.rpxnow.com has not forwarded their Privacy Policy."

For a site as simple as this one it's worked out pretty well. Easy to drop in and 1 less thing to think about it.

Thanks for the privacy warning - we'll look into it.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#55

Wow, this is pretty upsetting because I have been working on the exact same idea as you. How long has it been up, what kind of volume have you been doing, and how long did it take you to make it?

According to the developer's blog, the site went live in December '08 and took about two weeks to build.

http://www.twobitoperation.com/blog/2008/12/23/announcing-pi...

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#56
post #50
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm, would you pay more than twice as much to target a demographic segment that was less that 50% of the population?

Why does it matter how big the segment is?

It would require more effort to get 50 responses from a tiny demographic segment than a large one, so I was wondering if having the price inversely correlated to the segment size was reasonable to an end user.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#57

I just used this site, and learned that 18-34-year-old women find a picture of me without a baby more attractive, while the 50+ demographic definitely prefers the picture of me holding my niece. Biologial clocks at work? Anyway, worth $5! ;) Well, sort of... I wish there was a way to view the votes by (gender,age-group) pair, but most of the respondents were female, so I think I'm interpreting the results correctly.…

Actually, there is a way you can view the votes by (gender,age-group,etc.) - click on the "Option A vs. Option B" tab right under "Who responded to your question?" Is that what you were looking for? If so, it's our fault for not making it more visible.

Thanks for the heads-up about the mturk job search - we're making tweaks so that those previews show a sample question from now on. Helps keeps the responses more random too.

Thanks for sharing it!

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#58
post #41

Great idea guys! If you have to time to come up to SF you should definitely drop by our Crowdsoucing Labor/Mechanical Turk meetup on June 10th. You can RSVP here: http://www.meetup.com/Amazon-Mechanical-Turk-Crowdsourcing-W... The Amazon VP of Mechanical Turk is going to come by to answer questions, and I'm sure she would love to talk to you all.

Thanks Lukas, I plan on being there. Looking forward to meeting up - you guys are doing some awesome things with MTurk.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#59
"You can spend hours at a coffee shop polling 50 random people or bug everyone you know, but you'll be getting a skewed population"

Not to rain on your impressive parade, but I'd consider the type of person that wants or needs to use MTurk to be a pretty skewed population too, just in a different way.

Not saying it's not valuable, it may well be, and certainly more honest than asking friends - but I would expect a fairly low-income or bored-teen demographic.

Actually, an interesting meta-survey might be to survey the MTurk population itself, see what they think, their incomes, political beliefs etc; might be an interesting use of this very service.

But enough nit-picking - congratulations on a great idea, swiftly executed.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my site - PickFu.com

#60
post #59

"You can spend hours at a coffee shop polling 50 random people or bug everyone you know, but you'll be getting a skewed population" Not to rain on your impressive parade, but I'd consider the type of person that wants or needs to use MTurk to be a pretty skewed population too, just in a different way. Not saying it's not valuable, it may well be, and certainly more honest than asking friends - but I would expect a fa…

survey the MTurk population itself

a few people have done this already

http://behind-the-enemy-lines.blogspot.com/2008/03/mechanica...

http://waxy.org/2008/11/the_faces_of_mechanical_turk/

Post reply on HN