Live data from Hacker News

Tox: secure messaging for everyone

tox.im

51–60 of 214 posts

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#51

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

Maybe it was just a coincidence..?

Nice logo by the way.

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#52
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Out of curiosity, why not use OTR for messaging?

Probably because OTR only works when both parties are online at the same time. Edit: that said I haven't looked at their solution. Maybe it has the same issues. Or worse.

Looking at their crypto code, it appears they assume both parties are online. There is a two way hand shake for key negotiation.

My guess was they wanted to handle things like video chat and file transfer that OTR doesn't handle. But at least for video chat, I don't think it NACL will work out of the box either

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#53

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

On your second link someone posted "it's funny...i came up with the exact same mark a few months back and presented it to a client. Almost uncanny how close it was to this."

Perhaps the person who made the logo for this project had the same idea as this commenter.

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#54

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

Honestly, I don't see the concept being so unique and original that someone else couldn't have come up with it independently, and frankly the Tox logo has a much nicer balance (in the Tox logo, the person/keyhole works much better, whereas in yours it doesn't really work as a "keyhole" in my opinion) than the versions you linked.

EDIT: The logo was originally made in /gd/ (4chan's graphic design board), and since the board is archived I managed to track down the thread it was made in.

Here's a somewhat different version that people were playing around with at first (which also featured a lock, a speech bubble and a keyhole doubling as a person):

https://archive.foolz.us/gd/thread/86081/#86375

Then someone thought about moving the speech bubble to the keyring here:

https://archive.foolz.us/gd/thread/86081/#87186

And then after some iteration they got to the current version:

https://archive.foolz.us/gd/thread/86081/#87235

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#55

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

I think this is a matter of coincidence. The lock and chat bubble leads itself to a familiar look. I'm pretty sure you aren't the first person to think of such a concept, and neither are we.

Besides, the icon was made by an anonymous person so it's not really like we can blame anyone.

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#56

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

[deleted]

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#57
post #5

It is unfortunate that this thing's name collides with tox, the testing tool.

Why not rename one of the two to: detox (it'd even make sense)

How about renaming this Tox to something else, since Python's testing tool has existed for quite a while.

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#58

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

Disclaimer: I am in no way affiliated with this company/person.

Is it possible that they simply had a similar idea? It doesnt appear that they lifted the logo as is. Look at the person in their logo; it looks quite different (it doesnt stop at the shoulders like yours does). Other things are also slightly different. These differences lead me to believe that they at least made their logo by hand. Now if it was inspired by yours i dont know. To be fair, that google link does NOT show me your logo anywhere on the page. Furthermore, I tend to go with the principle of Hanlon's razor[1].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon's_razor

Re: Tox: secure messaging for everyone

#60

Oh, I see you helped yourselves to my Secure Chat logo - http://dribbble.com/shots/479881-Secure-Chat http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/165288 https://www.google.ca/search?q=secure+chat+logo - first page hit too Not cool at all, "cool guys around the world". -- (edit) Regardless of whether this was copied, over-inspired or independently conceived (but let's be realistic here), the generally accepted rule of the game…

We definitely did not steal. People were making mockups for weeks.
Post reply on HN