Live data from Hacker News

How to properly plagiarize a website

infinum.co

51–60 of 139 posts

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#51

This is nothing. Our 100k line vod web app was ripped off wholesale, with a new backend built from scratch, and repurposed to show pirate content. This was some serious engineering chops and time investment that went into a ripping off a site with hundreds upon hundreds of templates and thousands of lines of js and ajax interacting with an unknown backend that had to be reverse-engineered. We discovered it because th…

Did you guys write an article about that? That sounds supremely interesting.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#52
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What? Are you saying they are arrogant for outing a plagiarizer?

I think he's referring to how they are arrogant for threatening them, sending them "design tips", and playing themselves up as sexy and dangerous all in the same message. They definitely have a valid point about the plagiarism but they're being really cocky and showy about it. Edit: Ya, they might have been trying to be funny or venting, I can understand that. But they really shouldn't have ANY kind of physical threa…

I think they are a bit angry and venting a bit..

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#53

am I the only one who doesnt find the sites that similar after all? Or to put it another way - neither of them seem particularly unique (fixed header, slider on top, broad sections and large footer) compared to many marketing sites these days?

You're not alone. In fact, at first I thought their sites were standard Wordpress templates. I was kind of surprised they actually built them by hand. They both consist solely of what I would consider standard elements and layouts.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#55
post #43

I can't decide if it's a general aversion to public complaining, or if this company is really as arrogant and self important as this article made them out to be. In fact, after the thuggish threats, I'm pretty sure it's arrogance.

What? Are you saying they are arrogant for outing a plagiarizer?

I'm not sure about what OP was thinking, but I felt the same way. The article seemed to have mixed messages. One was, "how dare you steal from us" and the other was "Everyone steals".

Looking at the two sites, they were both using such common web design styles these days, that I would have assumed they both based their site off of someone else's.

If I were them, I would have stuck to the second argument, realized that no idea or design is a unique snowflake and everyone steals constantly.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#57
I worked at an AV company where I wrote a small video capture application that feature some basic CMS features. After a while it started to become a pain to maintain, so we decided to look for something off the shelf. The first vendor to come in and demo a product showed us a UI that was our design, pixel for pixel, with only the name changed.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Responding well to them? Their design is a standard template - slider below a menu, 3 columns below that, brands/testimonials below that, large footer. The only similarities I really see are the structure of the templates, and both look like they're from bootstrap, so I'm not sure what the stealing is complaining about.

I wonder if you're design blind? I've met a few people like that before. If that's all you think there is to a design, the 'standard' layout, you've missed a lot. Are you seriously going to tell me you can't see the similarity between: http://www.infinum.co/services http://kintek.com.au/services/ That most websites don't have that curve, or the spacing on the left/right or the little bar above the menu rather than be…

I'd say I'm design blind. From the examples in the post I would say, yes the sites have a passing similarity, but many, many company webpages look very similar to those two. The color schemes and layout details are different, the logos are quite different and the wording is different. So, to me, this is not plagiarism. Perhaps a telling comment on the sameness of a lot of design on the web.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#59

am I the only one who doesnt find the sites that similar after all? Or to put it another way - neither of them seem particularly unique (fixed header, slider on top, broad sections and large footer) compared to many marketing sites these days?

Yes, I just posted the same sentiments before I saw your comment.

Re: How to properly plagiarize a website

#60
post #43

I can't decide if it's a general aversion to public complaining, or if this company is really as arrogant and self important as this article made them out to be. In fact, after the thuggish threats, I'm pretty sure it's arrogance.

What? Are you saying they are arrogant for outing a plagiarizer?

No, outing the plagiarizer was appropriate. The tone of the post was what was arrogant.
Post reply on HN