Live data from Hacker News

My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

mynsarecords.com

51–60 of 86 posts

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#51

Before I put up MyNSARecords, I was curious as to whether more people would want a copy or want them deleted. Thought you might find it interesting: the "want a copy" crowd outnumbers the "delete" crowd by about 4 to 1.

Makes sense to me =) I just asked for a copy. I want to know what they are tracking and how fully, also a Freedom of Information Act sounds like they are more likely to comply than to Quash it. Of course, I would like to have it deleted after I get my copy...

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#52
post #51

Before I put up MyNSARecords, I was curious as to whether more people would want a copy or want them deleted. Thought you might find it interesting: the "want a copy" crowd outnumbers the "delete" crowd by about 4 to 1.

Makes sense to me =) I just asked for a copy. I want to know what they are tracking and how fully, also a Freedom of Information Act sounds like they are more likely to comply than to Quash it. Of course, I would like to have it deleted after I get my copy...

There should be nothing in the way of requesting both, I suppose. You could write the NSA and the FISC a motion to provide a copy and then destroy. shrugs

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#55
post #54

You should submit it to a few subreddits, too.

I did, but Reddit has a nasty habit of deleting my posts, generally silently (so it looks to me like they're still there but no one else can see). I was actually silent banned from Reddit for a year by an automatic spam filter's mistake. Really sucks.

You all can feel free to try on my behalf tho! Perhaps you have a more established account.

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#57
post #53

Can't I just give them my name, and my Google Voice number, and in return get all the information they have on me or will they only give me the information they have on my Google Voice number?

You need to provide an address for them to send you the information. :)

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#58
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't have a full understanding of it, but I think a Motion to Quash basically asks the court to say "This information was collected illegally or outside the investigative scope, and you may not use it as evidence (and thus must destroy it)"

It seems like the distinction that the NSA is trying to make is that, it's not illegal to possess the data, only to look at it. That argument may even extend to automatic processes that aren't seen by human eyes, who knows. If you happen to get a warrant in the future, you'll be able to "travel back in time" to see all communications of the person in question. The most maddening part of all this is that no one outsid…

Correct that this appears to be their argument, but that argument holds not a chance. Imagine if police searched houses randomly but "weren't allowed to use what they found unless they got a warrant." I believe this argument will be squarely and unanimously rejected by SCOTUS.

Re: My NSA Records - Submit a FOIA Request or Motion to Quash

#59
post #48
post #2

Doesn't a FOIA request have fees associated with it? Will the government just bill you for it when they provide documents?

Technically you want to submit a Privacy Act request to get records on yourself which is different than an FOIA request. But the NSA will just deny the request with a form letter.

The form you fill out says under both FOIA & PA. :) I got you covered. ;)
Post reply on HN