Live data from Hacker News

Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

intrade.com

51–58 of 58 posts

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#51
post #50
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not even close to libelous in the U.S., even if false.

I imagine saying a financial institution has lost all of it's customers money (without evidence) would be considered libellous in most countries.

It might be in most, but not in the U.S. You basically have to cause actual damage, have malicious intent, and actually be factually untrue. In the U.S. the comment you're speaking about would be considered mere speculation/conjecture.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#52
post #29

Whoa, I thought anyone today already knows that words "market"+"prediction"="scam"

Iowa Electronic Market is run by the University of Iowa. It seems to be accepted that it isn't gambling and it isn't a scam.

While Intrade might have been mismanaged, there is nothing fundamentally dishonest about a prediction market.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#53
post #51
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I imagine saying a financial institution has lost all of it's customers money (without evidence) would be considered libellous in most countries.

It might be in most, but not in the U.S. You basically have to cause actual damage, have malicious intent, and actually be factually untrue. In the U.S. the comment you're speaking about would be considered mere speculation/conjecture.

I assume it depends on a state basis, but IMHO the OP comment doesn't read like speculation, it reads like someone making a factual statement with the intention to influence the readers perception of the company in question.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#54

Intrade shutting down? Huh, what are the odds of that?

There was speculation, especially in the run-up to the 2012 Presidential election, that some of the pricing differences between Intrade and Betfair were due to the higher risk associated with trading on Intrade. So it is thought that market prices on Intrade may in fact have taken the likelihood of this event into account.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#55
post #18
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is that currently the closest thing to a prediction market is Bets of Bitcoin, and they use probably the bizarrest set of rules you have ever had the misfortune to lay eyes on. So.. not really an alternative at all except for the most wildly mispriced bets on it (where you can be sure to come out with a profit regardless of how much the rules screw you). I see the wiki lists 2 other prediction markets, bu…

Prediction markets don't necessarily have to be real currency and it's a misconception that they are only accurate if you're using real money. We have run a prediction market using fantasy currency for years: http://home.inklingmarkets.com . We also run run private markets for companies...

Of course they don't have to use real money. But if you're happy with playmoney, nothing stops you from, say, just writing down predictions and checking how they ultimately do. (I do just this; great practice and useful in many ways.)

However, we shouldn't forget that many people aren't going to contribute their time and expertise without a concrete reward. Nor do I blame them.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#56
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is that currently the closest thing to a prediction market is Bets of Bitcoin, and they use probably the bizarrest set of rules you have ever had the misfortune to lay eyes on. So.. not really an alternative at all except for the most wildly mispriced bets on it (where you can be sure to come out with a profit regardless of how much the rules screw you). I see the wiki lists 2 other prediction markets, bu…

Thanks for exposing a market opportunity! Sounds promising, in the right jurisdiction.

Yeah. I keep hoping someone will do a bitcoin version of Intrade as a Tor hidden service. It's the logical next step.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#57
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How are you determining the accuracy of your market predictions?

Here's a blog post we wrote a few years ago about it: http://blog.inklingmarkets.com/2008/05/judging-prediction-ma...

You don't specify when you are sampling the market. It often wouldn't be surprising, or useful, that a market correctly predicts an event the day before it occurs.

Re: Intrade Ceases Trading Activity

#58
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Care to elaborate for the ignorant among us?

Markets are unpredictable.

Interestingly enough, online prediction markets do not predict the markets, just as online dating sites don't date anyone. They provide a platform for other people to try and predict. Of course, many of these people would be wrong, but that doesn't mean the platform itself is a scam.
Post reply on HN