Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 64 posts

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#51

There is probably more money in this as entertainment than architecture. And less liability. How many of us have made house plans at some point?

Oooofff I want there to be some truth to this statement.

The SIMs ran my life for a while and today if there was a "build this plan into a real house" as a lead gen...

My gut says the crossover/cross-sale is just too hard and niche, but if it works, it sounds like one of those genius ideas.

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#53

This is a really interesting product and the demos look really good too! I was just wondering whether or not there has been any plans of implementing a chat feature into Drafted. Looking to learn more about what you guys are building.

Thank you! At some point we will. We are working through the basic generative interactions mechanics and manual editing to allow for people who need to get more nuanced to do so and then will incorporate a chat layer for those that want to stay at a high level (pure intention level).

Just tried out the app itself, and from first glance, it looks good. As I started to click around, I noticed that a lot of features were unresponsive, such as when I was trying to select my palette or view my profile - the buttons were unclickable. I also have some other questions as well. Mind if I shoot you a connection and message on LinkedIn so we can discuss this further?

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#56
I do a lot of work in the AEC space. This is an interesting idea but I don't find the results very compelling. There are huge houseplan catalogs out there full of mediocre plans. I'm guessing this is trained on that sort of data as both the floorplans and the elevations look more like what you would get from those catalogs, and not what you would get from hiring an architect.

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#57
I couldn't believe all the negative feedback, so I took a good look on the homepage too. Yeah, it's all AI slop, only it's funded by YC. Honestly, for me, I don't see myself using this. I might as well start from a 2d sketch on my notebook for some ideas and wire up Claude with blender. I think an average user might just ask ChatGPT or Gemini to give them some ideas. This is one of those products where you might try it out, but there is no recurring model here. Home building by itself isn't a recurring exercise, so not really sure. It could possibly work as a Pinterest of sort for housing plans, but even then, I could very well use Pinterest for this as it already has a great collection of housing plan ideas. For example:

https://pinterest.com/nairveena20/houseplans/

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#58
post #57

I couldn't believe all the negative feedback, so I took a good look on the homepage too. Yeah, it's all AI slop, only it's funded by YC. Honestly, for me, I don't see myself using this. I might as well start from a 2d sketch on my notebook for some ideas and wire up Claude with blender. I think an average user might just ask ChatGPT or Gemini to give them some ideas. This is one of those products where you might try…

I like your house plan collection. Thanks for sharing.

You should try creating a house and let me know what you think.

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#59

I do a lot of work in the AEC space. This is an interesting idea but I don't find the results very compelling. There are huge houseplan catalogs out there full of mediocre plans. I'm guessing this is trained on that sort of data as both the floorplans and the elevations look more like what you would get from those catalogs, and not what you would get from hiring an architect.

That's cool. What kind of work?

It is more of that data. Most people can't afford an architect and almost everyone who buys a templated plan from one of those sites ends up changing it for another $5k-$15k with a drafter (lower cost) or architect (higher cost).

For a lot of people, they like a house, but they want to fit it to their needs and don't know how.

We are hoping to bridge the gap through lowering the cost to ideate and iterate on home designs.

Re: Launch HN: Drafted (YC P26) – Models for residential architecture

#60
post #50

Im curious, where did you get all the training data? Actual blueprints? Or it the training data pictures of homes? Or a mix?

They are actual blueprints!

Looks really cool, as both a software developer and a custom home builder I think this is great.

I noticed it can only draw hip roofs.

You need more alot more training data of good looking houses. I'm sure it's taken a lot of effort to get these things working, but these houses are lacking some character to me.

I think this is a great idea. Have you thought about trying to hire architects or builders?

Post reply on HN