Live data from Hacker News

Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

adafruit.com

51–60 of 354 posts

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#51
post #26

I really struggle to see where this fits in to most use cases. The appeal of the Pi back in the first iterations was being a relatively cheap linux computer with GPIO.

It's useful if you need GPIO but not $350 useful. Nowadays you can get used office mini PCs with a 10th gen Intel and 16GB RAM for like $200 and they'll come with an SSD. No idea why anyone would buy an expensive Pi.

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The linked model has 16x the amount of RAM that $35 model had. You can still get a 1GB model for less than $50.

You can get an Intel N100 NUC with 16GB ram, 500GB ssd on Amazon for less though. This is just very expensive for what it is.

These perform way better and have similar efficiency, too. Case, power supply, cooling, and storage are all included too. If you don't need GPIO then you don't need a Raspberry Pi. If you do then consider using a microcontroller (Pi Pico, ESP32, etc.) first.

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#54
post #31

This is hilarious considering you can easily[1] get a whole ARM laptop with 16GB for $425 all day, and that will also include a screen, keyboard, trackpad, battery, and storage. I first checked for Mac Minis and interestingly they are much closer to $650 for similar specs. And obviously if Intel is fine for your use case, either the N100 type of mini PC or, my preference, an off-lease HP, Dell, or Lenovo USFF PC, wou…

For what it is worth, an M4 mac mini is also like 30-50x faster. Like, legitimately.

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#56
post #44

I’m surprised to see those legacy USB ports on a board where space savings is important. Do they do it for backwards compatibility with older cases and housings? And am I correct to see that the USB-C only does power? How do you connect your pheripherals to this board?

I think legacy USB peripherals are very common. Almost all of my peripherals are legacy USB; I think I only own a single USB-C peripheral. Old stuff still works, so I don't need to buy new ones.

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#57
post #31

This is hilarious considering you can easily[1] get a whole ARM laptop with 16GB for $425 all day, and that will also include a screen, keyboard, trackpad, battery, and storage. I first checked for Mac Minis and interestingly they are much closer to $650 for similar specs. And obviously if Intel is fine for your use case, either the N100 type of mini PC or, my preference, an off-lease HP, Dell, or Lenovo USFF PC, wou…

> This is hilarious considering you can easily[1] get a whole ARM laptop with 16GB for $425 all day, and that will also include a screen, keyboard, trackpad, battery, and storage.

That "laptop" will also absolutely smoke the Pi on performance, too:

https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/24356484?baseli...

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The linked model has 16x the amount of RAM that $35 model had. You can still get a 1GB model for less than $50.

You can get an Intel N100 NUC with 16GB ram, 500GB ssd on Amazon for less though. This is just very expensive for what it is.

If you just want a tiny desktop computer, sure. The reason to buy a Pi is for the GPIO and the well-established ecosystem.

Re: Raspberry Pi 5 – 16GB RAM

#59
The Raspberry Pi 5 uses LPDDR4X. Finding 16GB (128Gb with a small b) chips in this size is not common. That memory chip is at least $200, probably more, even at the scale that they’re buying them.

I’m glad they’re making it available for the rare cases where it’s needed, but for PR purposes it would have been better if they just discontinued the 16GB model until RAM prices came down. I’m getting tired of hearing “Raspberry Pi 5 costs $300” now from people who have no reason to buy the 16GB version.

The 1GB version works well for simple Linux shell work and embedded projects. It’s $50.

The 4GB version works well for GUI work. Let’s be real: It’s a slow device and not a desktop/laptop alternative in 2026, so 4GB goes a long way for the use cases where you want to do basic GUI work. $110 for the 4GB model (if you shop not at Adafruit)

EDIT: Adafruit prices are higher for some reason. 16GB Pi 5 is $305 on other sites.

Post reply on HN