Live data from Hacker News

Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man to a violent crime

timesofsandiego.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man to a violent crime

#51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It didn't lead SDPD to any person at all. It led them to a red Alfa Romeo with tinted windows. Flock doesn't do facial recognition. It's a real-time search engine for cars on video feeds.

as I posted elsewhere, a tool that requires perfect human oversight to avoid harming innocent people is a problem

People are writing as if an ALPR directed these cops to arrest someone. No, it didn't. They asked it where they could find a red Alfa. It accurately told them. It's not the tool's fault it didn't occur to SDPD that there could in San Diego be in fact 2 red Alfas.

Re: Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man to a violent crime

#52
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

as I posted elsewhere, a tool that requires perfect human oversight to avoid harming innocent people is a problem

People are writing as if an ALPR directed these cops to arrest someone. No, it didn't. They asked it where they could find a red Alfa. It accurately told them. It's not the tool's fault it didn't occur to SDPD that there could in San Diego be in fact 2 red Alfas.

Is it also not the tool's fault that cops keep using it to stalk people?

https://www.404media.co/cops-keep-getting-arrested-for-using...

Re: Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man to a violent crime

#53
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People are writing as if an ALPR directed these cops to arrest someone. No, it didn't. They asked it where they could find a red Alfa. It accurately told them. It's not the tool's fault it didn't occur to SDPD that there could in San Diego be in fact 2 red Alfas.

Is it also not the tool's fault that cops keep using it to stalk people? https://www.404media.co/cops-keep-getting-arrested-for-using...

I'm inferring from the fact that you've now switched stories that you concede the point I was making. Thanks! I'm less interested in debating this new story you want to talk about.

Re: Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man to a violent crime

#54
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it also not the tool's fault that cops keep using it to stalk people? https://www.404media.co/cops-keep-getting-arrested-for-using...

I'm inferring from the fact that you've now switched stories that you concede the point I was making. Thanks! I'm less interested in debating this new story you want to talk about.

That's pretty sad, because I was making the same point you still lack the rigor to comprehend... ah well
Post reply on HN