Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is having issues now

githubstatus.com

51–60 of 132 posts

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#51
post #2

For the past hour, the PR or Issues pages would load with 0 items. Occasionally, there’s an error toast mentioning ‘failure to fetch data’.

Oh, it's even more fun than that. If you sit there hitting F5, sooner or later you will get a proper page load. So some small subset of the servers is vending the correct data, and the rest not

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#52
post #20

I am once again here to say that my gitea has better uptime since I deployed it. It's way snappier too. Long live self-hosting. Diversify from the cloud, build your own!

What's your general increase of cost and maintenance overhead? How many devs and repos do you have?

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#54
post #11

Github has been having issues since the Microsoft acquisition. https://damrnelson.github.io/github-historical-uptime/

That's damning. I wonder what it will look like over the next 13 months as more and more code is written by ai

Too bad Copilot's having issues and as such it will take longer for recovery.

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#56
post #46

Hate GitHub being down, plus hate AI stealing your code? Join sourcehut--it has worked great for me, and I'd love to see it flourish as a platform.

How is sourcehut different? It’s just yet another centralized service.

At least it doesn't go down as often, I guess. I think most users do want a centralized forge that gives them discoverability and star graphs.

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#57
post #11

Github has been having issues since the Microsoft acquisition. https://damrnelson.github.io/github-historical-uptime/

This is not to say that things haven't gotten worse over time, but...

I don't think that chart shows what it seems like it shows. There were plenty of pre-2018 outages that don't show up there: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1545696000&dateRange=custom&...

An alternate interpretation of that chart is "After the microsoft acquisition, they got serious about actually tracking outages."

That said, anecdotally, it's felt much worse over the last 6 months. I'd guess it's a combination of MS-induced quality drops and AI-induced scale increases.

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#58
post #46

Hate GitHub being down, plus hate AI stealing your code? Join sourcehut--it has worked great for me, and I'd love to see it flourish as a platform.

How is sourcehut different? It’s just yet another centralized service.

> It’s just yet another centralized service

Yeah, collaboration usually requires some sort of centralisation. Whether that is the LKML+git.kernel.org, gitlab.gnome.org, salsa.debian.org or Sourcehut, or GitHub. At least Sourcehut isn't completely proprietary and shoving AI down your throat at every possible chance. The same can be said for Codeberg and almost any GitLab CE, Gitea or Forgejo instance

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#59
post #11

Github has been having issues since the Microsoft acquisition. https://damrnelson.github.io/github-historical-uptime/

And when they introduced "Free" for everyone including teams, well I tried to warn everyone that centralizing everything to GitHub was not a good idea [0] 6 years ago.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803

Re: GitHub is having issues now

#60
My new projects do not use GitHub, and will not use GitHub as anything more than a mirror. Two nines of reliability isn't enough for devtools.

GitHub is in a tight space right now. The pace of software development is increasing and they are in a load-bearing position. In addition, their GitHub Copilot license was a massive loss-leader both directly costing them money, and making the traffic problem even worse. Simply put, they aren't prioritizing scaling and reliability like they need to be in this current situation and instead are focusing on feature build outs that boil down to being Microsoft's AI Middleman Salesperson.

Their position is hard, but they are potentially fumbling the ball in a big way. I for one don't trust them to not be down right before I want to do a production deploy.

Post reply on HN